8 way Jan 2.0 cus of doc save (on the cop who won the CC). The Cop has a guilty. Do you lynch the guilty (due to possibly being lawyer), or NL?
Scenario 2:
6 way Jan 2.0. Cop has 2 innos on blues, doc is CC'ed. (the other person is uncc'ed ORC) Do you lynch in Doc CCs for autowin (if Lawyer is lynched) or do you NL because you fear MYLO (and end up in the exact same situation in 3 way but with no autowin).
dude ur the only 1 who thinks NL is optimal literally every1 has told u why it isnt
deletedover 8 years
If we NL'ed in the 8 way and dzanek died, pranay would literally be confirmed mafia and the final one would be between spotting and Director, making it auto.
If you died, I would've lynched pranay over anyone else considering he was my top fos. I orc'd him every night minus the last one to prove that.
You don't acknowledge the fact that pranay was buddying you and I thought he was very scummy, and you said before that mafia couldn't buss into autoloss, so why would pranay buss spotting? There was literally no evidence that game to make me townread you in any way before the 6 way, and the only people to call you town were the morons who still don't understand what graveyard vision is. There have been threads about it. Maybe if the town members that were alive actually heavily agreed with you in the day told me that I was wrong, then I'd listen to it. I'm not gonna listen to people that weren't in the game itself or were dead during the 6 way. They don't understand what it was like from our POV, plain and simple
Town lynching the guilty on Day 2 was the right play
On Day 3 the village should have lynched in doctors; lynching in doctors gave the village a 50% chance at autowin
But Iceaac, this one game doesn't mean ThirdAug is necessarily is a terrible player, you need to stop being so unnecessarily extreme/toxic and you need to stop blowing things out of proportion all the time whenever you get mad, it's silly and childish. You could honestly earn a lot more respect around here if you changed your attitude
The reward of lynching lawyer is greater than the associated risk of MYLO in that game.
Miller has no choice but to claim miller (and really, the miller was null and wasn't overtly towny).
If we NL'ed in 8 way and dzanek died, then now its even worse for town because guilty is alive and lawyer CCs me.
If we NL'ed in 8 way and I died, then cop now has 1 guilty report and cop is forced to scumhunt.
I had no cofidence in the cop (who made it clear she was indecisive) and I was not going to trust you when you were spamming and being toxic all game. Lynching was the optimal choice (TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GAME AND NOT JUST RAW PROBABILITY).
Even on raw probability alone, lynching the lawyer is near autowin for town.
No lynching forces the mafia to kill the doc. They have no other choice but to kill the doc, which leads to 3 way, a 50-50 between blues.
Why would you NL and end up with the exact same situation when you have a 50-50 right there and autowin if you lynch right?
deletedover 8 years
The cop didn't have an inno on dzanek, something is wrong with your brain. They had no choice but to sacc you or dzanek, it was a 50/50 shot at autowin if we no lynched, and it was the optimal move.
@Ideal: You're still the only one who thinks NL, NL is the optimal choice mate. You don't even have to be in the game to understand why lynching both times is the optimal choice in Jan 2.0
I'll leave it to a mod/mentor to explain to you why because I've explained best as I can and you still can't seem to understand.
