My top 3 Maf roles are:

Ventriloquist
Voodoo Lady
Fiddler

My top 3 Vil roles are:

Cop
Santa
Trollsmith

My top 3 3p roles are:

Fool
Old Maid
Politician

If I got the kind of roles you like, granny and oracle would also be in the category.

What kind of MAFIA roles do you like? I see you're all mentioning town roles (or 3rd parties, rarely).

I like the Bomb a lot. It's one of the only roles with a reason to lie about what they are to their allies in normal circumstances. The Fool is good too, in concept. Wish they couldn't mafside....

Those are the only two roles I can think of that really mix the game up in the way that I like.

Bleeder, Cupid, and Anarchist. Buuuuut they're all pretty darn fun, in my opinion. >w>;

In this lobby, they would probably be:

deputy
miller
anarchist

OLD MAID
CUPID
CTHULU!!!!!