Like the use of “surely,” a rhetorical question can be a substitute for thinking. While rhetorical questions depend on the sense that “the answer is so obvious that you’d be embarrassed to answer it,” Dennett* recommends doing so anyway. He illustrates the point with a Peanuts cartoon: “Charlie Brown had just asked, rhetorically: ‘Who’s to say what is right and wrong here?’ and Lucy responded, in the next panel: ‘I will.’” Lucy’s answer “surely” caught Charlie Brown off-guard. And if he were engaged in genuine philosophical debate, it would force him to re-examine his assumptions.
Master Atheist Hitchens's razor: "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence." ConnorMachiavelli says he has kissed a girl but where is the proof??
Master Atheist Hitchens's razor: "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence." ConnorMachiavelli says he has kissed a girl but where is the proof??
who cares?
I care!
deletedalmost 9 years
Master Atheist Hitchens's razor: "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence." ConnorMachiavelli says he has kissed a girl but where is the proof??
Master Atheist Hitchens's razor: "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence." ConnorMachiavelli says he has kissed a girl but where is the proof??
yes but the answer is irrelevant because that proves nothing about whether or not you're a loser at life
I bet you haven't.
A long time ago in like 2009 you made a comment on my profile that was like, "Don't ever care what other people think of you," and reading that comment was a really formative experience for me. Thanks, man.
Yea, you used those words to wrangle a faction of the site under your tutelage.
A long time ago in like 2009 you made a comment on my profile that was like, "Don't ever care what other people think of you," and reading that comment was a really formative experience for me. Thanks, man.
Yea, you used those words to wrangle a faction of the site under your tutelage.
deletedalmost 9 years
yes but the answer is irrelevant because that proves nothing about whether or not you're a loser at life
well unlike you i am not obsessed with being liked i don't care if some idiots have disliked me
I used to say this when I didn't understand who I was.
A long time ago in like 2009 you made a comment on my profile that was like, "Don't ever care what other people think of you," and reading that comment was a really formative experience for me. Thanks, man.
i care what others think of course if i want to be thought of in a certain way i just particularly am indifferent towards being disliked
ConnorMachiavelli, if you were on a spaceship and it ran out of gas then everybody on the spaceship would agree that you'd be the first person they'd burn for fuel.
well unlike you i am not obsessed with being liked i don't care if some idiots have disliked me
I bet you would wish that you had cared more if you wound up on that spaceship.
it's an unrealistic proposition and i wouldn't be the true loser at life because i didn't live it in fear of others opinions
Yeah, well, I bet you have never kissed a girl.
deletedalmost 9 years
ConnorMachiavelli, if you were on a spaceship and it ran out of gas then everybody on the spaceship would agree that you'd be the first person they'd burn for fuel.
well unlike you i am not obsessed with being liked i don't care if some idiots have disliked me
I bet you would wish that you had cared more if you wound up on that spaceship.
it's an unrealistic proposition and i wouldn't be the true loser at life because i didn't live it in fear of others opinions
well unlike you i am not obsessed with being liked i don't care if some idiots have disliked me
I used to say this when I didn't understand who I was.
A long time ago in like 2009 you made a comment on my profile that was like, "Don't ever care what other people think of you," and reading that comment was a really formative experience for me. Thanks, man.
ConnorMachiavelli, if you were on a spaceship and it ran out of gas then everybody on the spaceship would agree that you'd be the first person they'd burn for fuel.
well unlike you i am not obsessed with being liked i don't care if some idiots have disliked me
I bet you would wish that you had cared more if you wound up on that spaceship.