Epicmafia

Petition: Remove report karma req

deletedalmost 10 years

Lets all be seriously how are you supposed to defend yourself? In reports waiting until somoene karmas you? Remove the karma requirement in reports it always been a nasty system to never be able to say anything on reports on you or vice versa especially for the new players

Remove the report karma requirement

38 signed

Remove the karma requirement from reports and be freely to comment

TheeCake

almost 10 years

Have the mods hand out +k whenever someone is reported so they can defend themselves.

Giga13

almost 10 years

Shamzy says

It would be cool though if there was a way that new accounts that are reported, and do not meet the karma requirement, can still defend themselves on the report. Only that user though, all other users that do not meet the requirement cannot. I may just be dreaming...

If a user is reported maybe if they were only allowed to comment on that report it'd be okay

deletedalmost 10 years

Shamzy says

It would be cool though if there was a way that new accounts that are reported, and do not meet the karma requirement, can still defend themselves on the report. Only that user though, all other users that do not meet the requirement cannot. I may just be dreaming...

As again as stated earlier

Then make it atleast that the reporter and the reported can post anything without having the karma requirement

Shamzy

almost 10 years

It would be cool though if there was a way that new accounts that are reported, and do not meet the karma requirement, can still defend themselves on the report. Only that user though, all other users that do not meet the requirement cannot. I may just be dreaming...

Giga13

almost 10 years

WolfODonnellz says

They will be able to spam when they reach 2000 points anyways all what it takes is 2000 points account to karma and then accounts that played atleast 20 games

So no stopping that just a delay

You do realize that this takes a while to do, right? The system we have is fine, it prevents multiple spam accounts from mucking up the site, as they have done before and as they will continue to do if this was removed. If you ban a spam account when there's no karma requirement, they simply make another account and start again 10 seconds later. If you keep the karma requirement, it takes them over a day to get their account back to a point where it can even obtain karma. That's a lot of effort. No offense but this is a bad idea and while all ideas are appreciated this one is just not great, sorry

deletedalmost 10 years

WolfODonnellz says

Then make it atleast that the reporter and the reported can post anything without having the karma requirement

deletedalmost 10 years

They will be able to spam when they reach 2000 points anyways all what it takes is 2000 points account to karma and then accounts that played atleast 20 games

So no stopping that just a delay

Miloo7

almost 10 years

Miloo7 says

answer to OP:

GasPedaI says

throwaway/spam accounts don't have 2000 points

Trolls and banned users will be able to spam the reports

deletedalmost 10 years

Im not saying to remove karma itself

Miloo7

almost 10 years

I didn't build up my karma all the way to 99 just so you can remove it before i hit 3 digits :(
answer to OP:

GasPedaI says

throwaway/spam accounts don't have 2000 points

deletedalmost 10 years

Then make it atleast that the reporter and the reported can post anything without having the karma requirement

deletedalmost 10 years

no, they can't, that implies they have enough points to karma each other, and throwaway/spam accounts don't have 2000 points

they can't give each other karma if they don't have enough points to karma each other lol

deletedalmost 10 years

They will spam anyways because they could just karma eachother

deletedalmost 10 years

no because garbage accounts would spam the report page

deletedalmost 10 years

Man i needed 420+ karma for dis it was impassible

Monk

almost 10 years

WolfODonnellz do you really have enough Karma to go around making posts like this? We really need to raise the requirement for this kinda stuff...

ISamEI

almost 10 years

That doesn't really make sense. Unless someone has some sort of defense for it, it should go.