I'm just going to leave this here:



Please note that "wins" and "losses" refer to the number of times gerry won/lost with that person in the game.

I think we all know slow was actually trying to prove gerryoat = luminica

Do you know when I started playing? My first gold heart game was halfway through the previous round. My performance doesn't change regardless of who I play with. Sorry for being a bad player.

Giga13 says

Alright, I've read gerry's defense and the games.

I feel really bad for gerryoat1 and luminica because it is very clear to me that you two were not cheating this round. I completely disagree with the verdict of cheating in the pastebin against gerryoat1, and as always that is only my opinion. But luminica, whether you realized it or not, you were playing in favour of gerryoat1 for a lot of his games. I'm sorry because a lot of users do this subconsciously, but when it happens over very many of a trophy runners games in a round, sometimes the trophy gets stripped. It's happened before, this isn't the first time. I can't go against four (three current) moderators and lucid. Lucid was correct to not give you two violations and I am firm in that belief, and I am firm in believing the correct outcome is occurring.

This is pretty much the same as the CocaCola/Zwink case, except more games were affected. This is just my opinion as always and I really do feel bad for you gerryoat1 because you're not only a good player but you didn't really do anything wrong. You just have to be careful with who you play with and be careful that the same person or people aren't consistently playing in your favour.

Giga, Gerry got off way easier than I did, considering we were falsely accused of similar things, except his situation was way worse. I was banned for suspectedly playing against my win condition and abusing meta when I still placed in the top 10 of the round. I don't think Gerry is entirely clean considering how poorly dream quakes did this round. That's just my input on the matter. I feel like Gerry should get an equal if not worse punishment for what he did....regardless of whether or not he role shared.

Its extremly dicficult to have a comp without reports

Alright, I've read gerry's defense and the games.

I feel really bad for gerryoat1 and luminica because it is very clear to me that you two were not cheating this round. I completely disagree with the verdict of cheating in the pastebin against gerryoat1, and as always that is only my opinion. But luminica, whether you realized it or not, you were playing in favour of gerryoat1 for a lot of his games. I'm sorry because a lot of users do this subconsciously, but when it happens over very many of a trophy runners games in a round, sometimes the trophy gets stripped. It's happened before, this isn't the first time. I can't go against four (three current) moderators and lucid. Lucid was correct to not give you two violations and I am firm in that belief, and I am firm in believing the correct outcome is occurring.

This is pretty much the same as the CocaCola/Zwink case, except more games were affected. This is just my opinion as always and I really do feel bad for you gerryoat1 because you're not only a good player but you didn't really do anything wrong. You just have to be careful with who you play with and be careful that the same person or people aren't consistently playing in your favour.

twist says

There's a distinct difference between backing your reads up with meta and flat-out abusing it

What's the difference?

There's a distinct difference between backing your reads up with meta and flat-out abusing it

he's not a mod anymore.

but yeah, that was a bad post for an at the time mod.

That bin was nearly as convincing as xxerox's bin on me and pereking cheating