I suggest a maf sided crier
Potion Maker is a big NO because dead people can see roles and etc.
Clown is fun but should have some kind of winning condition imo
also copy pasting ideas i liked from the thread:
[Yogi]
Death
Third party
Cannot die
At the beginning of the game, receives a randomized numbered list of all players in the game (excluding himself).
The goal is to have players die in the order written on the list.
Wins if 3 players die in a row in the correct order.
Does not affect Town or Mafia win conditions.
[deleted]
Archer: Townsided, starts with an "arrow". Can choose to shoot someone during the day, with a 1/5 chance they are killed instantly and archer is not revealed, 1/5 chance they are killed instantly and archer is revealed, 1/5 chance they are hit and die the next day and archer is not revealed, 1/5 chance they are hit and die the next day and archer is revealed, and 1/5 day they are hit but survive and archer is not revealed. During the night the Archer can go to the target that they shot the arrow at (if they are still alive), retrieve it, and shoot again the next day.
[JohnnyAppleseed]
Blood Prophet:
At the start of the game, selects three players.
If all three players die before any other win condition is met, the blood prophet wins.
Bleeds out on D1; appears as bleeder to town.
Third party
[Scindo]
Maniac
-Stabs one person per day.
-Has meeting and as soon as they select yes it "stabs" the last person to speak and they die.
-Wins if Survives and kills 2-3 people
-If Jailed or visited by a Shrink it becomes a normal blue villager
-3rd Party
[lilin]
Gambler
-Shoot for the stars!
-At day time, picks a person to go to a meeting with them at night
-At night time, gambler and the chosen person will play rock-paper-scissors
-The one who loses will die
-Town-sided
also obligatory:
https://epicmafia.com/role/9956