first vote on you is from a bad player voting baselessly, then scum pile on, people decide to go with the flow and vote the larger wagon
that said you were making some rather terrible cliched arguments, about things like her asking you to retract and time to claim, which are raelly meaningless. day 1 ccs blow but if you're using bad logic it's liable to get you voted. can't say for sure why you got voted though because it's far from an all star table