Back to General Discussion

Why does God allow Suffering?

over 10 years

I am going to summarize what is linked below.

Basically Satan questioned God's right to rule mankind. Since then many men have questioned God's right to rule mankind. Man tries to rule themselves, and look at the results. We have a multitude of corruption, hypocrisy, and evil, all from our leaders no less! With time, this evil world will end up destroying itself, which is what God will step in to stop, after finally proving that Mankind is incapable of ruling itself.

Matthew 24:21,22 "21 for then there will be great tribulation such as has not occurred since the world’s beginning until now, no, nor will occur again. 22 In fact, unless those days were cut short, no flesh would be saved; but on account of the chosen ones those days will be cut short."

Read paragraphs 11-18 from the following link.

http://www.jw.org/en/publications/books/bible-teach/why-does-god-allow-suffering/

Any questions I will be happy to answer, knowing full well that this is the internet :)

Also for answers to other questions take a look at these:

http://www.jw.org/en/publications/bible/nwt/introduction/

http://www.jw.org/en/publications/books/bible-teach/

over 10 years
The entity described in the Hebrew Bible is not parallel to God.

He is at his "right hand".

He is not a demonic munster in Hell. At all.
over 10 years
More from that site.

“Set thou a wicked man over him: and let Satan stand at his right hand. When he shall be judged, let him be condemned: and let his prayer become sin” (Psalms 109:6-7).

This statement reaffirms the idea that Satan is God’s prosecutor, identifying the sins of man. In the same book Satan is blamed when David takes an unlawful census (1 Chronicles 21:1), but another account of the same story clarifies that it was God who made David take the census – possibly through His agent ha-satan (2 Samuel 21:1).




But the most interesting is the reference found in the book of Zechariah, which shows, in part, the evolution of Satan from God’s angel and prosecutor to a being of evil and impurity.

“And he shewed me Joshua the high priest standing before the angel of the Lord, and Satan standing at his right hand to resist him. And the Lord said unto Satan, The Lord rebuke thee, O Satan; even the Lord that hath chosen Jerusalem rebuke thee: is not this a brand plucked out of the fire? (Zechariah 3:1-2).

For the first time in the Torah we have Satan resisting God and God rebuking Satan, not as His servant, but as something contrary to God. A Satan resisting God’s will and in need of rebuke runs counter to the teachings in Isaiah, Job, Ecclesiastes and Deuteronomy, all of which credit God with the exclusive control over good and evil.

Given the above theme, it’s probably no surprise that the book of Zechariah was set after the Babylonian exile and during the rebuilding of the Temple of Jerusalem, during the reign of the Persians. One of the book’s dominant themes is the imminent start of the messianic age as seen through multiple visions, another indication of strong Persian influence, within Zechariah’s writings.
over 10 years

Piney says

I can see where you're coming from. But how do you explain that part in Job where God is talking to Satan about Job? (Job 1:6-12 and then again at 2:1-7).


Or is that what you mean by 'one of his minions?' Because if Satan really was just an innate evil then that wouldn't really make sense; God according to both the Old and New Testaments does not possess any evil whatsoever.



He isn't evil. He's a fictional creature that's sort of like an assistant. Judaism borrowed HEAVILY from pagan beliefs and other folk legends.


http://mythsofchristianity.com/god-and-the-devil/satan-and-job/



In fact, the term ha-satan is a title, not a name, and it belongs to an angelic member of God’s council who travels with the sons of God (Elohim.)

“Now there was a day when the sons of God (Elohim) came to present themselves before the Lord, and Satan (ha-satan) came also among them” (Job 1:6).

The term ha-satan means “the adversary” or “the prosecutor” and it is sometimes used to refer to an obstacle. In the story of Job, ha-satan acts as a criminal prosecutor, with God as the ultimate judge. He is not autonomous and he does not make evil. Instead, he points out or identifies the evil actions of mankind to God while leaving their fate to the dictates of God himself.

In the story of Job, ha-satan, the prosecutor, presents himself before God, along with the sons of God. God addresses ha-satan and asks him to consider the righteousness of Job. Ha-satan alleges that Job only worships God because God has blessed him so greatly, but if those blessings were to be removed, Job would curse God.







Again...the Jews do not believe in an sort of devilish creature that was conjured up by the Greco-Romans in the New Testament. He doesn't exist in their theology and this is the only time he is mentioned as an entity in the entire book.
over 10 years

pieattack says

I am a Christian, and I believe Satan was an angel who wanted to be like God. They are fighting in the spirit world right now. Satan has made us also like demons, however, Jesus died for us so that all who believe in him will have eternal life.


Believing things that you make up based on poorly interpreted knowledge you learn in Sunday School is probably why you aren't a very intelligent person.

There is no such occurrence in all of the Bible. Do some research.
deletedover 10 years
Isaiah 45:7 "I make peace and create evil. I the Lord do all these things."

Lamentations 3:38 "Out of the mouth of the most High proceedeth not evil and good?"
deletedover 10 years

QRich says

Satan is nothing more than an embodiment of all that is against God.

Referring to him in anything more than the metaphoric(and nonsensical) way it is referred to in the Bible just shows ignorance and naivety.

The only reference to "Ha-Satan" in the entirety of the Old Testament was one of God's minions. Satan = Accuser

This transposed to enemy....

So A satan is simply an enemy against God. Which of course, is rather vapid to go into deep nonsense talk about how innate evil is against God and that suffering is a result of that....but the very few literate scribes that wrote these stories down thousands of years ago didn't really think these things through. Probably because they didn't really have to.

For example, the story of the Serpent in the Garden of Eden makes no logical sense. Again, there was no concept of some Lex Luthor-esque enemy against God established in all of the Old Testament, so the idea is generally a random serpent suddenly started talking and telling a woman to defy God. Out of all these perfect things in this perfect utopia for some bizarre reason God just happened to slip in an evil talking serpent...way to go YHWH.


Not to mention, the entire argument is a giant red herring and really detracts away from the fact that an alleged omnipotent "intelligently designed" a f****ed up creation just for the sake of seeing it do f****ed up things.






I can see where you're coming from. But how do you explain that part in Job where God is talking to Satan about Job? (Job 1:6-12 and then again at 2:1-7).


Or is that what you mean by 'one of his minions?' Because if Satan really was just an innate evil then that wouldn't really make sense; God according to both the Old and New Testaments does not possess any evil whatsoever.
deletedover 10 years
Trips there is something comforting about looking at my -1 and knowing it is you. Thanks for lookin out for me man :)
deletedover 10 years
yeah like those robots who can't catch anything idiot robots why are you all so bad
deletedover 10 years

Piney says

Makes sense I s'pose. Probably a lot more than the standard (and the really annoying) 'It's all part of God's plan' answer from your typical neighbourhood priest/minister.

"Why did God allow the Holocaust to happen?"
"Oh, don't worry, it's all part of GOD'S PLAN."

"Why did God allow 9/11 to happen?"
"It was also part of his PLAN."

"Why does God allow innocent people to die everyday?"
"Plan."




Nothing is God's fault. People are just bad.
deletedover 10 years
I am a Christian, and I believe Satan was an angel who wanted to be like God. They are fighting in the spirit world right now. Satan has made us also like demons, however, Jesus died for us so that all who believe in him will have eternal life.
deletedover 10 years

QRich says

Damn it! I messed up the code on this one's AI!

It has no idea how to do anything! It won't even catch things!

Stupid robot.

Go to hell! >:[


lol
deletedover 10 years

QRich says

So basically I will sum these paragraphs up without citing a f****ing parable like I'm an idiot or something.


A: Omnipotent being makes flawed creation
B: Flawed creation is not subservient
C: Omnipotent being creates billions more flawed creations and sulks at how bad they are.
D: Megalomaniac omnipotent punishes billions of flawed creations for being designed wrong...decides to let them suffer instead of fixing them.


This is the answer to this hypothetical question in a nutshell.


I noticed that s****y website likes to use bad, yet relatable examples.

So a better one would be a person making a robot to throw things. Instead it only caught things. So the person blames the robot and sends it to hell.

Seems legit.


sorry couldnt really hear u, i think u were holding ur fedora over ur mouth or something
over 10 years
Damn it! I messed up the code on this one's AI!

It has no idea how to do anything! It won't even catch things!

Stupid robot.

Go to hell! >:[
over 10 years
My plan is if I simply do nothing, the robots will eventually stop malfunctioning and throw things as designed.

If they cannot manage to stop malfunctioning before they run out of batteries I'm sending them to hell. No questions asked.

Now excuse me while I make more malfunctioning robots...

Oh brb....I screwed up the glue on this one...let me just scrap this one before it even gets a chance to malfunction. I'll send it to hell anyway.

You know I am a perfect robot designer you know.
deletedover 10 years
THROWING THINGS IS A SIN, ROBOT YOU IDIOT
deletedover 10 years
SCREW YOU ROBOT WHY DON'T YOU STOP SINNING
over 10 years
So basically I will sum these paragraphs up without citing a f****ing parable like I'm an idiot or something.


A: Omnipotent being makes flawed creation
B: Flawed creation is not subservient
C: Omnipotent being creates billions more flawed creations and sulks at how bad they are.
D: Megalomaniac omnipotent punishes billions of flawed creations for being designed wrong...decides to let them suffer instead of fixing them.


This is the answer to this hypothetical question in a nutshell.


I noticed that s****y website likes to use bad, yet relatable examples.

So a better one would be a person making a robot to throw things. Instead it only caught things. So the person blames the robot and sends it to hell.

Seems legit.
over 10 years
That scripture means absolutely nothing at all.

It's also from the Jew Book.

Good going Christian.
deletedover 10 years

Piney says

Makes sense I s'pose. Probably a lot more than the standard (and the really annoying) 'It's all part of God's plan' answer from your typical neighbourhood priest/minister.

"Why did God allow the Holocaust to happen?"
"Oh, don't worry, it's all part of GOD'S PLAN."

"Why did God allow 9/11 to happen?"
"It was also part of his PLAN."

"Why does God allow innocent people to die everyday?"
"Plan."




u just dont understand, look up isaiah 55:9
over 10 years
Like if I was going to take an extremely poorly transliterated book in a de-facto dead language, change all of the words with ambiguous meanings to mean what I want them to mean...no to mention that...given the fact that these people were illiterate these stories weren't even written until decades, even hundreds of years later like a game of whisper down the alley that just went on way too long.....I would totally make a mythical bogeyman out of something that was totally understood at the time to mean "accuser".

I would even give him horns and a pitchfork because munsters are scary.
over 10 years
The story of Adam and Eve is somewhat of a metaphor detailing humanities inherent rebellious nature against God as well as innate "evil" qualities.


It's a bit of an oxymoron when you consider "intelligent design" but, hey...plotholes tend to exist in poorly devised folk tales.


And of course, queue the zealots retconning their stupid plotholes and answering every one with an all-encompassing bogeyman who clearly does not exist within their own stupid fiction book.
over 10 years
Satan is nothing more than an embodiment of all that is against God.

Referring to him in anything more than the metaphoric(and nonsensical) way it is referred to in the Bible just shows ignorance and naivety.

The only reference to "Ha-Satan" in the entirety of the Old Testament was one of God's minions. Satan = Accuser

This transposed to enemy....

So A satan is simply an enemy against God. Which of course, is rather vapid to go into deep nonsense talk about how innate evil is against God and that suffering is a result of that....but the very few literate scribes that wrote these stories down thousands of years ago didn't really think these things through. Probably because they didn't really have to.

For example, the story of the Serpent in the Garden of Eden makes no logical sense. Again, there was no concept of some Lex Luthor-esque enemy against God established in all of the Old Testament, so the idea is generally a random serpent suddenly started talking and telling a woman to defy God. Out of all these perfect things in this perfect utopia for some bizarre reason God just happened to slip in an evil talking serpent...way to go YHWH.


Not to mention, the entire argument is a giant red herring and really detracts away from the fact that an alleged omnipotent "intelligently designed" a f****ed up creation just for the sake of seeing it do f****ed up things.
over 10 years
Ehm, why does god allow?
deletedover 10 years

carolineeee says

i thought it said surfing


surfboarT
deletedover 10 years
i thought it said surfing