Back to General Discussion

Are you a boy or girl or other?

deletedover 10 years

I want to make a poll to see how many players are from each gender! It's interesting to know and plus voting is fun!

You identify as:
75
Boy
53
Girl
18
Other
over 10 years

Sammie says

gay men identify as men. they are not women.


So being gay = being trans? But you get loads of men who are characteristically male?


Sammie says

trans women identify as women.


But you just said transgender people identify as the opposite sex, so surely a transgender female would identify themselves as male?
over 10 years
gay men identify as men. they are not women.

trans women identify as women. they are women. not every trans woman is attracted to men the same as any cisgender woman isnt necessarily attracted to men.

how many gay men actually want to have a womens body? that makes no sense and is offensive to both gay people and trans people
over 10 years
i am trying to educate? how ami being conmdecsending at all? i answered yourq uestion. i have satan forum blocked so i couldnt read his comment.
over 10 years
satan the *** are you on about? honestly this is a good reasonw hy i have youbloc ked on forums because you spout the most ignorant garbage about trans people i've ever seen.
over 10 years
Jesus Petri I'm genuinely interested in this and all you're doing is getting defensive. Educate me, but don't look down your nose and feel as if I'm insulting you here, because that's not the case.
over 10 years
wow jupiter.

i mean, most MtF trans people are attracted to boys exclusively (I believe) , and that doesnt make them gay , it makes them straight

and if an MtF person was attracted to girls theyd be a lesbian


etc.
over 10 years

Satan says

people see trans as a more permanent option to being homosexual. if it was more socially acceptable to be transsexual, i feel like people would move towards the transsexual route, rather than homosexual route.


I was referring to Satan's comment.
over 10 years
sexuality has nothing to do with gender identity, simply put.
over 10 years
Gender and sexuality are completely separate things
over 10 years
Is there a requirement for homosexuality in being trans? Surely if you're socially identifying yourself as one gender (i.e. having the characteristics of), you don't necessarily need to be homosexual? You could have a girl who's a real tomboy - loves everything masculine - but still isn't lesbian? And visa versa?
over 10 years
Why do you feel the need to question their gender? Who cares, it's not a freakin MIT survey lol
over 10 years

shinchan says

I am a semidemisexual otherkin transfat/transracial(cis presenting) genderless social justice activist and anti-racist. My otherkin form is a slightly burnt apple pie with a bite taken out of it that has been dropped on the floor. I am triggered by apples, cleaning products, and the colour peach. I'm am outraged that this survey doesn't fully account for me. I am a special snowflake. Die Cis Scum.


nice made up words there mate.

you cant just throw a bunch of words together and end in sexual and have it count.

honestly, screw you. being trans isnt the same as pretending to be some special snowflake or what ever. this isnt Tumblr, its real life. these are real issues.

emmer its because these girls have always said they were girls and theyve never said anything except that and i hav eno reason to believe they arent girls? if they posted in this thread nad suddenly said they were actually boys, for real, then fine.

the whole point of this poll is to gather data. it ruins the data if you have cisgender girls voting as boys.
over 10 years

EmmerrLouise says

Got it.

So why did Sammie have a problem with girls voting 'male' on the poll? Do we know whether they socially identify themselves as male or not? And what exactly is the threshold for 'sociological identification' - how "manly" does one feel before they're considered trans?

No jokes or anything - genuinely curious.


usually, at least in my experience, people see trans as a more permanent option to being homosexual. if it was more socially acceptable to be transsexual, i feel like people would move towards the transsexual route, rather than homosexual route.

but that is my inexperienced ideology, i'm not a sociologist so I don't know the exact parameters or anything.


thats why people (me included) are calling petri out. like it was totally unnecessary to post that comment, lol.
over 10 years
I'm a guy. Who knows why people think I am a girl. So weird.

I Also sociologically identify with being a guy, but then again, why wouldn't I. I AM A GUY!
over 10 years
Got it.

So why did Sammie have a problem with girls voting 'male' on the poll? Do we know whether they socially identify themselves as male or not? And what exactly is the threshold for 'sociological identification' - how "manly" does one feel before they're considered trans?

No jokes or anything - genuinely curious.
over 10 years
I am a semidemisexual otherkin transfat/transracial(cis presenting) genderless social justice activist and anti-racist. My otherkin form is a slightly burnt apple pie with a bite taken out of it that has been dropped on the floor. I am triggered by apples, cleaning products, and the colour peach. I'm am outraged that this survey doesn't fully account for me. I am a special snowflake. Die Cis Scum.
over 10 years
XX chromosomes = female

XY chromosomes = male

that is how biological SEX is determined.


sociological GENDER is what that person identifies as.

trans are people who are BIOLOGICALLY one thing but identify with the OPPOSITE sex.

(since trans means opposite!)
over 10 years

Sammie says

genitals =/= gender


I always assumed gender was determined by the chromosomes rather than what's going on in your pants. Some women are born without the necessary 'hole' (sorry for bad vocab) but still have the characteristics and, more importantly, the DNA makeup of a female.

Does not having a *** make you any less of a man? That's like suggesting girls with small breast are not fully female.
over 10 years
chicken if you repeat that slur again youre getting reported for hateful comments.

ok.. so what if you didnt have male genitals anymore? would you exist in some sort of gender ambiguous state because you dont have genitals?


genitals =/= gender
deletedover 10 years
HAHAHAHAHAHA THERE ARE NO GIRLS ON THE INTERNET, SILLY TRAPPER KEEPERS
over 10 years

chickenhide says

I was born with male genitals, therefore I am male. That is the way the world works. Sorry, trannies.


umm tr*nnie is a transphobic slur pls dont say it
over 10 years

chickenhide says

I was born with male genitals, therefore I am male. That is the way the world works. Sorry, trannies.


well, normally i would agree with u, but there's a such thing as intersex which is when you have a mixture of the two biological sex's physical characteristics!

however trans means opposites, so basically if their sex is male (or female), and they feel like a female (or male) in order to escape certain death under sharia law (i.e. homosexuality), they become females (or males) using surgery!
over 10 years
I was born with male genitals, therefore I am male. That is the way the world works. Sorry, trannies.
over 10 years
This site is full of boy cooties D:
over 10 years
thanks!!!