Back

Report #254,000

Report Details

closedover 6 years
[APPEAL] This is not a gamethrow game. I killed sheriff with a vest because I thought blacksmith would have vested Mister. It was a fault, I did not do it on purpose. https://epicmafia.com/report/253996

Hi JonSnow, I know you are one of the good mod with transparent mindset. Could you help me investigate this report. I did not throw game on purpose cuz I kill the wrong person with vest.

Thanks.
over 6 years

The spamming votes + the drop-line vote caused to my mishammer on hooker. Hence I did not throw game.
over 6 years
Also how come you're so aware of my positioning? Or how I did during the round? You clearly saw me as a threat.
over 6 years
Not true Memoji, you pointed out right after that I was a beast or something like that because I climbed so quickly.
over 6 years
Also I'm not trying to get him suspended? How is it my fault he already has a vio this round I'm not aware of. I simply want my heart back because this game was thrown. If he threw a different game I wasn't a part of that has nothing to do with it.
over 6 years
MisterPresident spammed his votes super fast and I was the one hammered by accident.

Back to the time when I played on Phoenixi with Mori that game. Her rank was outside of the top #20 or #20.
And Memoji was around 6 or 7.

If mods have the turn back time function to check our games and our ranks at that time.
over 6 years
Also him hammering the hooker made it so we couldn't hook the bs which would have given us autowin regardless and there would be no 50-50 vest situation. In any case, he seriously screwed our chances. And MisterPresident didn't vote super fast, and he left the vote up for several seconds before it was hammered by Phoenixi, which is proved by someone else commenting in the middle of the two votes.
over 6 years
Focusing on a single point is also called cherrypicking. When you judge phoe's game as a whole it's clear there is no intent to throw.
over 6 years
Phoenixi threw maf autowin and that's that.
over 6 years
Also I don't care about silver trophy, I much rather prefer the bronze one cause I already have silver and gold lol
over 6 years
I'm not even friends with BSM lmao
over 6 years
okay, to the people that think hammering hooker "got him this far in the cc anyways"

you need to remember the sheriff shot a blue already and a blue was vested/hit

mafia lynching ANY town is autowin. even if they lynched sheriff, there are 2 blues alive and 1 bs. 1 blue is confirmed blue because a bs can not vest themself. that means you can kill one of the town, and hook the other

you get a kill 100% of the time because you either a. kill bs, who cant protect himself or b. kill the blue, who will not get a vest because you hooked the only other potential bs
over 6 years
anyways, as discussed, the gamethrowing intent is based upon the hammer of his hooker, not the 50/50 kill on vests

i WOULD be more inclined to believe it wasn't an intentional throw if it wasn't for a few things:

hes in a game with an opposing runner (mori) of his main, memoji

there were two votes on phoenixi as well and i'd be probably be more careful of hammering myself or my partner if it was a 2-2-2 split with 2/3rds mafa in it

mrpresident telegraphed he was voting courier earlier, and phoenixi couldve left the vote on him. this i don't think has too huge of a dwelling because he couldve been nervous he was getting tricked/etd blah
over 6 years
Even if he HAD killed the hooker on purpose, Mister literally EXPLAINED that it was the only reason that he town read him over the ACTUAL Cop.

This action was the only thing that got him so far imo, so mistake (highly likely) or accident it doesn't deserve to be vio'ed just so you can win a bloody cup.
over 6 years
Thank you Torr, it all seems to add up to me - Pheonix didn't mean to say he was going to hammer BallerCharles, it was an obvious slip of the tongue (why would he hammer Sheriff without any votes on them, which would make him appear scummy later on?).

He clearly intended to vote theCourier, as has been stated elsewhere, but he slipped due to MisterPresident's spam-voting.

As I've said, I can clearly see Mori's motives - he is currently fifth place on the scoreboard and, although he has two hearts remaining, he could only potentially get the bronze cup if he wins two more games. HOWEVER, with Pheonix wrongly violated he has potential to claim the silver cup.
over 6 years
Ok i understand what happened on d2 btw.
If you go back to the game, you see d2 that MisterPresident is spamming votes on TheCourier6, which takes two lines (example with a standard resolution : https://imgur.com/a/nKFF5MR)
If phoenixi is underneath Misterpresident in his window (which we can't verify), and if phoenixi is spamming votes too (which he was), then his vote would constantly change between two lines, between MrPresident not voting (taking one line) and voting (taking two lines). So he could have mishammered based on this.

It's hard to explain but it's pretty standard when playing on computer. I've already mishammered once in gnh because of this.
over 6 years
Mori - we can all clearly see what your plan is, you want him to be suspended from the competition so you have a chance of getting the bronze/silver trophies.

His hammer was an obvious mistake - you are OUTRAGEOUS privately messaging a mod, who is biased towards you due to friendship, to try and get your own way.
over 6 years
Also yes, I did message before I reported. Because I wanted to ask for opinions first. My comment was made after the thing was reported and handled simply because I was asleep after I messaged. I was planning to report that myself.
I also have no preference for or against bam as a mod, I should clarify. He's simply one of the mods I messaged, and the message tab is glitching, I couldn't ever find Jonsnow to send him the message, for example, even though I wanted to. I should also clarify the first person I sent the message to was SausageDog.
over 6 years
I can screenshot the message I sent to mods last night though. Why would I lie about it?
This isn't about the vest, it's about the hammer. Phoenixi made up THREE DIFFERENT EXCUSES why he hammered the hooker. In game he said he tried to vote Baller, in the report he said he tried to vote Courier, and now he's saying the game glitch. He's clearly lying.
over 6 years
Also, the Mod denial has just made a comment in another report;

"also, his excuse is kinda ? because he said he was attempting to hammer a guy that had 0 votes on him, and if he had voted the guy, it'd literally do nothing since kicks weren't in and the votes would've been split 2-2-2-1-1"

This is wrong... TheCourier, who Pheonix claimed to have been aiming to hit had two votes already (MisterPres and TheCourier himself, his vote would have made a third and would have seen him hammered.

Denial seems to be protective of the user Blacksnake's clear trolling/Mod abuse - he was the user that closed my report earlier on, which clearly showed Blacksnake gamethrowing.
over 6 years
Mori's comment in the report; https://epicmafia.com/report/253996, was made AFTER the report was closed and moderated lol
over 6 years
Vile. Pheonix mentioned IN GAME that he slipped when voting for the hooker and actually meant to vote theCourier, I also slipped while attempting to vote Pheonix and ended up lynching the hooker too.

There was no gamethrow attempt, and Mister - who hammered Townread over Pheonix - actually stated that it was Pheonix's hammer of the hooker that made him a town read.
over 6 years
Well officially BSM played "judge jury executioner" (10/10 mod) but Mori said the following in the initial report :


---

I messaged blacksnakemoan with this game. In fact I messaged other mods and other players asking for their opinion before this was reported. I would have reported myself but I wanted to know what people thought first. The reason why this was reported was because he quickhammered the hooker when the hammer was on town - There was no reason for him to do that. He wouldn't have done that on his running alt.
Everyone else that's read this game agrees it was sketchy, specially since it's him on his alt against another runner.
Can the game be refunded please?

---

So yes, apparently in our justice system you can just asks judges to look privately into something without suing anyone, with the added bonus that you get to choose the judge who handles the issue.
over 6 years
I think Mori and Blacksnake deserve the vio in this case. Disgusting corruption.
over 6 years
Oh, Mori reported it? Should have known, what a troll. Mafia would have had no problem winning this game if he'd have managed to bloody town-tell properly.
over 6 years
Oh while we're at it...is it common policy for runners to not use official channels and report and instead contact friend mods one by one to "inquire" about a game? How is this not corruption? Care to explain that Mori? Were you scared that if you reported it wouldn't be handled by your favorite mod?