Back

Report #130,774

Report Details

closed
IAmRobert
→
Rondar
over 10 years
[APPEAL] https://epicmafia.com/report/130653 ... are you for real? Like this is the most blatant fucking GT/anti town play ever. Self-voting in a mylo/lylo situation forcing a town loss should cause a 24hr ban, not a NV. Get f***** real. I want my heart back, but even if I don't get it back, this needs to be f****** vio'd. This comp, not some fucking unranked game. Stop this bull****

from the forum: That may have been the worst ruling I've ever seen. She cant' even justify her play it was that bad. It makes no sense and leads to her being lynched 100 out of 100 times. She self-voted too. That's GT. If she talked and tried to not get lynched we had a chance to win the game. Instead she forced me to lynch her. Please don't be f****** dumb. Like this type of happens all the time. It's unnacceptable and letting it happen while people are running bastardizes the point of competitive games.
Police
over 10 years
Rondar didn't think this player was intentionally trying to lose / give up, so despite it being kinda bad play, he didn't give the vio. Also check your tone in dealing with mods if you wanna be taken seriously by them, just a tip.
Police
over 10 years
Game throwing is based on intent, yo.
IAmRobik
over 10 years
Cause I was mafia that game jackass. And having empirical evidence is the best way to prove that the mod's decision is f****** wrong
IAmRobert
over 10 years
unsurprisingly, town would have lost this game because gov decided to OT off of me after the same "play". too bad i got called away to a work emergency. https://epicmafia.com/game/3890530
IAmRobert
over 10 years
Oh what a surprise...i guess i'm not the only person that sucks at this game and assumes that person who cc's gov is mafia. https://epicmafia.com/game/3890472. Can't wait to continue this experiment until I get reported for GT and then I can point to this stupid f****** ruling to show how being a dumb f*** isn't GT or ISP.
deletedover 10 years
You deserve the loss because you (shock) lynched the town, instead of the mafia.
IAmRobert
over 10 years
Like, I try to reason and try to figure out why we are voting for someone, and raw decides to just off, claim gov and not try. Like how the do I deserve blame and how do I deserve a loss in comp play for him playing like that. That's so infuriating.
IAmRobert
over 10 years
S/HE SPOKE 5 TOTAL TIMES IN 2 DAYS. THE FIRST WAS "YES, HELLO" ... THE OTHER WAS TO CLAIM GOV. THAT'S NOT F****** PLAYING THE GAME. THAT'S ISP. THAT'S GT. THAT'S PLAYING AGAINST WIN-CON. LIKE NONE OF HIS PLAY IS TOWNIE AND HE SHOULD BE EMBARRASSED. "M" IS FOR MOTHERFUCKINGPIECEOFSHIT
Hibiki
over 10 years
not giving up. pretending to be gov who is going for gov achievement.
deletedover 10 years
You should refile it under M, for mindnumbingly stupid reports.
IAmRobert
over 10 years
Seems like it. Should I refile this report under ISP? S/he's literally giving up and letting gov decide the fate of a person that doesn't want to save themselves
Hibiki
over 10 years
why did you assume he was mafia? why would he make such a bad play as town or mafia? because he wanted town to lose? o.O
IAmRobert
over 10 years
"I give up, I'm gov. I'm goign to OT" ... THIS IS NOT A TOWNIE PLAY. IT'SN OT EVEN A PLAY. IT'S NONSENSE. IT'S GT
IAmRobert
over 10 years
RAW BASICALLY ISP'D AND SELF'D. THAT'S LIKE THE DEFINITION OF GT. JESUS CHRIST
Hibiki
over 10 years
if raw gets cc'd as gov, there's a clear blue, which is still better than no clears (gov dead)
IAmRobert
over 10 years
You don't know her intent. In fact, when she saw the report, she didn't even justify her actions. She just said "dude...." I'm calm. I'm calm and I'm annoyed that you think there's nothing wrong with this.
Rondar
over 10 years
And please realize that we don't give out GT vios for a single set of moves or a single plan. We base it solely on intent.
Rondar
over 10 years
Then you're left with the very regular in-game decision of "is she maf and wifomed or is she town and wanted to help?".
Rondar
over 10 years
I'm sorry but you're wrong here. I tried explaining it to the best of my abilities. Please review it once you've calmed down a bit. I'm positive every mod will agree with me as well.
IAmRobert
over 10 years
Imagine she's mafia. She does this. Doesn't die. Rescinds her claim. Then you lynch whom?

Imagine she's town. She does this. Doesn't die. Rescinds her claim. Then you lynch whom?
IAmRobert
over 10 years
ADDITIONALLY, HER "PLAY", LEADS TO ANYONE BEING ABLE TO CLAIM GOV ON LAST DAY BECAUSE GOV CAN'T OT. YOU'RE F****** WRONG
Rondar
over 10 years
Robert if it had worked, there would be a clear at 3 way lylo. All you needed to was lynch someone else.
Rondar
over 10 years
Robert there's no such think as "routinely GT". GT requires a player to intentionally play against their win condition.
IAmRobert
over 10 years
OR SHE CAN JUST TRY AND NOT BE A LIL B**** AND NOT GET LYNCHED AND LET US LYNCH MAFIA WITHOUT HAVING ME TO YOLO AN OT. THAT'S ALSO A F*****G PLAY.
Rondar
over 10 years
What Hibiki said. I tried to explain that in the original report too.