Back

Report #93,734

Report Details

closedover 10 years
[APPEAL] This is a blatant gamethrow. There is NO WAY that it can be considered a roleswap. If it was a roleswap THERE WAS NO WAY TO TELL WHICH ROLE SHE WAS SWAPPING WITH. This cannot be considered a roleswap. This is flat out GT. If it was a roleswap Nik wouldnt have HARDCLAIMED cop.
over 10 years
When is a decision going to be made?
deletedover 10 years
Nikysha isn't stupid enough to think GenocYda would retract as PR there, and had no reason to hard CC Hamzz at that point.
over 10 years
Sorry, I posted a verdict from another report in this one: having 10 tabs open is sometimes not the best idea ever! Apologies.
over 10 years
OBVIOUS G
over 10 years
I'm leaning towards sustaining the original verdict. It looks like Nikysha thought he was roleswapping with Geno, and therefor thinking the real cop was in fact mafia. Was it bad play? Yes. I fail to see 'not having the intention to win/ not wanting to win' though, especially because Nykisha has no game throwing history. So I agree with a note, in case this kind of behavior DOES continue. However it's a hard report to handle, since the cc he made as blue did in fact get the real PR lynched. So just to be sure I'd like to discuss this with other mods. We'll get back to you all and thanks in advance for your patience.
over 10 years
Nik's reason for claiming had nothing to do with Geno. That is indisputable proof that it was not an attempted roleswap. Boom.
over 10 years
Nikasha claimed pr before Geno said "i hope you will die"
over 10 years
Hardclaiming cop when the other player claimed pr and retracted isnt a roleswap. That is a GT
over 10 years
there is NO WAY to justify claiming cop as blue. there were two other pr claims (me and hamzzz) it was completely uncalled for.
over 10 years
she cc'd unccd cop!! her actions directly resulted in losing the most important role in the game
over 10 years
it cant be a roleswap. she claimed cop and was DIRECT cc's