Back to General Discussion

Competitive G&H + Classic

about 6 years

https://epicmafia.com/setup/1483430

Can someone give me advice on how fun/scumhunt based/thought through this setup looks? If you find anything gamebreaking about it, I would like feedback. Thanks!

Is this setup ok for Comp? Does it look like it will yield relatively fair gameplay?
9
No
4
Needs work
1
Yes
about 6 years
People will use whatever meta is the strongest, which isn't neccesarily what you've written, especially considering this setup hasn't been played yet. You need to try it out to figure out what the best strategy is for both maf and town.
about 6 years
Just because you write a strat doesn't mean people will play according to it, and considering it's likeness to the aformentioned sheriff hipfire setup, it's likely they'd just play it the same (nl d1, doc on Sheriff, shoot into d2.)
about 6 years
In case you didn't read the strategy, both nillas are supposed to claim d1.
about 6 years
i can HELL YEAH there so you have my support
about 6 years

htennis says

Maybe a framer instead of a lawyer? Not sure how that would affect things.


Would make things a LOT more interesting and would possibly balance things. Still would be a different take on Sheriff hipfire setup, but could at least market it as a varient of it.
about 6 years
Maybe a framer instead of a lawyer? Not sure how that would affect things.
about 6 years
g&h sucks
about 6 years
This is basically a modified version of Sheriff hipfire setup, just with a doc instead of blacksmith, and a second nilla isntead of lawyer.

Town win % will likely be higher than maf win %, as all innos are cleared by cop, leaving little room for doubt

Do I think it's fair and compable? Yeah, but it's less balanced than blacksmith one, so no one will play it.