Aye and I agree, I was just saying that as a rule setups that are 60/40 either way aren't typically fun either and are not considered comp-worthy for a good reason.
balance just means that given both sides commit equal level plays and demonstrate equitable abilities who is more likely to win. doesn't really mean a setup is fun or requires skill in the first place.
And as to that clown-fiesta of a setup called 'Christmafia' somehow being 49/50, all that proves is that a series of towns with pork pies for brains has been butchering the stats.
If mafia don't kill a pr Night 1, town ought really to be winning 75%+ of games due to the sheer amount of town PRs that exist and that are also, if the players have any brains, practically uncc-able by the scum.
Only scenario in which mafia should have a relatively even chance is if they manage to luck out and hit that disgusting Mary Sue of a pr 'Santa' N1.
If you switched the completely useless mafia Stalker and 'Nilla for Janitor and Informant then you might have an in theory balanced setup, but as it is town has genuinely no excuse not to make it a pointfarm this round because of how impotent the mafia's power is in it compared to the town.
balance is overrated and a bad way of measuring whether a setup is good. a must act with blue-granny-mafia is a balanced setup so it's automatically good.
No cc'able pr, if none dies n1, santa can have a confirmed town + a gun in game for town + caroler can give out a carol + snowman can stop a maf pr (with maf prob being less than 3, in those conditions)
WAY TOO EASY TO HAVE TOWN AUTO, shouldn't be allowed in comp.
The character that goes by he name "maldito" has been throwing against me and I am making a claim and stand. U think u can bully me? U think I won't fight back? Enough is enough. I had a detective search this joker and it turns out his name is Henry and he lives in Detroit. Listen here Henry, ur days are numbered. My craigslist hitman ad now has 4500 views and counting.
