lyncher can have a day one loss. Also the king maker situation

so what’s the rebuttal against paranoid pandemonium then

I don't think fool nor lyncher are comp viable roles.

People playing fool would be likely to just troll or be annoying to intentionally get lynched, or just ISP to get kick lynched and both of those scenarios would be terrible for competitive mafia

Lyncher is slightly better of a suggestion, but I think that the swings in points would be far too ridiculous to justify, not to mention rolling lyncher would more than likely just be a free loss, and unfairness in win % is a big reason as to why setups are removed in the first place

not to mention it would muddle cheating investigations and regular reports more than they already are

alio and paranoid pandemonium are two setups with third party roles that still require strategy from all players and genuinely make you think and It’s A Crying Shame that neither is comp eligible.

i was thinking of running but if i cant comp some wacky stuff lie that.. whats the point

yah ive seen that thread b4, it says its not law, so im wondering if i can comp a fool, lyncher, or alio-like setup, it deosnt answer my question at what u guys would do

Sure! Here's a really great but old thread on this topic from one of the old admins

https://epicmafia.com/topic/59974

it should answer your questions

bump