Epicmafia

Spot the Mech Fails

almost 7 years

For those of you who claim to be good at this game; think of this as a fun challenge. This isn't a thread to shame mechanically weak players (hence, we'll call them inconsistencies). I found around 5 inconsistencies in this game at first glance, but I'm pretty sure there's more.

Maximum points after 48 hours wins the thread, one free GRS, and a sticker in the distant future.

Game in question- https://epicmafia.com/game/6328025/review

This is very objective; there's no opinionated answers in here.

Point system:

Spotting a logical inconsistency = 1 point (per line)

Spotting a mechanical inconsistency = 1 point

Pointing out why a certain player was confirmed town or mafia at any point of time = 2 points

Giving the optimal move for a player at any point of time = 2 points

Explaining why there existed logical and mechanical inconsistencies = 3 points

Finding who's accountable for the end-result (this one's got me puzzled too) = 5 points

Banned user multiplier = 2x (compounded per banned user spotted in-game)

You may rehash someone else's spots but will receive half the points unless you present proper reasoning.

Torreador

almost 7 years

Oo it's my game. I'll bite, but I don't like the holier than thou tone of this post, so i'll post some inconsistencies from our dear santa.

Asking to lynch ISP, hammer a blue then claim you were 3/3 : Logical inconsistency

Saying in graveyard I slipped because I can't be caroled twice : Logical inconsistency, selmie was caroled n1.

Is it possible to mention other games here? Cause in the following game : https://epicmafia.com/game/6328053
Snowman decided to snowball going into 3waynoclear, when he could have gotten a potential autowin carol if he novisited. "Weak mechanically". But hey, let's not shame.

blacksnakemoan says

Logical insconsistency for Torreador at day end. "Shooting nonclear who hides items is optimal" but how do you shoot the person who hides a gun?

When I say "shoot" i mean "throw a snowball" and when i say "item" i mean "carol". In this setup you can softclaim pr and telling your target has an "item" :) I just needed an excuse to avoid shooting hooker.

blacksnakemoan

almost 7 years

Intrepid was conf mafia as soon as he said "o, well then" instead of laughing or denying it.

JM123 is a moron and no one should have a stalk code, they did nothing wrong there.

Logical insconsistency for Torreador at day end. "Shooting nonclear who hides items is optimal" but how do you shoot the person who hides a gun?

I can't be bothered reading more, but Zhu had all 3 day 1 lmao

redino

almost 7 years

-skyfang is a banned user (reason: JM is a mod and so he knows who is banned)

Night 1 optimal moves: Skyfang vote Zhuorb. Intrepid vote Zhuorb. Torreador vote Zhuorb. Hooker hooks Zhuorb. Stalker stalks jenny10.

Night 2 optimal moves: Skyfang vote Zhuorb, Intrepid vote Zhuorb. Hooker hookz Zhuorb.

JM123

almost 7 years

ill take a quick look

-skyfang is a banned user

-n1 stalker should always make a code, codes are easy to make and theres no reason not to do it since it helps the other 2 mafs

-d1 intrepid was noob for claiming mafia, you should never do that. he could still cc something to try or fish.

-also leaving all prs unccd is probably not the best idea

-d1 maf didnt ball who he was told to ball lul kinda obv

-d2 who would belive torre would be vested by zhuorb in that context? lmao get out of here

-d2 selmie should start the rxn test outside torre

-if selmie was conf hooker like torre tried to make she would ball one of the prs to avoid autoloss, instead of her 'partner'

-typical noob town allowed maf to blitz on kicks because asking for selfs instead of leading bw kek

-the biggest responsible for that loss is jenny for openly allowing a blitz, and she was even actually hammering maf

there's more stuff, but cba to get it all

deletedalmost 7 years

www.EpicMafia.com/game/6323122

www.epicmafia.com/report/236470

www.pastebin.com/vgW9s6Uw

I didn't confirm vilden as mafia, but I did confirm that it was 98% auto

and also I gave optimal moves relative to their point of view using gambling.