ultra/bob: clearly the most controversial one. first i'll quickly say the 6th town is obviously one of elmo or dari. thus leaves ultra/bob and cammy as the last possible town. we could just acknowledge the fact that cammy was auto rejected as people believing she's scum and that would literally make ultra town right now, end of story. but let's delve deeper. bob, while completely oblivious to much of the later game, was rather eager to get information in the missions, and accepted all of them. while that signals he accepted some that had scum on them, you have to actually see what he's saying. this is where i actually had a noobread on him and believed him to be likely not scum. but that's contentious, admittedly. however, when ultra replaced him, it became quite apparent that this particular role was town. he entered the game, allowed himself to be caught up on what's happened thus far, and proposed an all town team (this one). if he was scum, he had a PERFECT opportunity to throw in another scum with him (likely in the elmo/dari pairing), double fail, and win the game outright. while he could play the long con to ensure he gets on mission 5 and fails that then, i personally don't believe ultra would do that.
conversely, cammy has had a scumread on arisuu since the beginning of this game. most recently today she said she didn't like ultra (he is her opposite in my pairings so that makes sense), lelmoo AND dari (one of them literally has to be good so why does she not like both?) and still doesn't know how to feel about arisuu, who could only be scum in cammy's eyes if ginga or vibrage was town. cammy leaned ginga based on her most recent posting, and i think it's pretty well established that ginga is quite scummy, so to see cammy push for ginga to go on a mission is rather sus.
in conclusion, that was a 5 town mission and we're fcking doing it again
ok i am home now and can fully explain why i believe that was a 5 town mission
me: i know that i am town
jeff: i've had a strong tr since the beginning of the game and it has not wavered. he has identified scum and town that line up (mostly) with what i believe to be correct.
alice: has had incredibly accurate reads on town and scum, she also was unaware of the 2 to fail rule on mission 4 and if she was scum she therefore would have failed that (i don't believe she's dumbtelling)
elfen: this was created by proxy of vibrage and ginga becoming scummier and scummier. if elfen was evil, those 2 wouldn't have been on it with him. you don't put 3 evil people on a 3 person quest, that's crazy. one of you could fail it and expose all 3 of you. if you're gonna fail mission 1, you do it by yourself and try to pin it on 2 town. therefore by process of elimination and sheer logic, elfen has to be good.
Yes but Jeff, if ginga's mission had been accepted and Lelmoo was good it would have passed, putting good up 2-1 with the 2 to fail mission up next. There's no way ginga would do that he's not an idiot
