Back to Epicmafia

Who's the better player

deletedover 7 years

there used to be a thread comparing dave (connor) and soben. dave got like 1 vote and soben had about 50 votes.

Battle 1 - Dyl vs JeffreyAaron. Winner: JeffreyAaron.

.

Battle 2 - Gerry vs Soda

.

Upcoming battles:

  • Battle 3 - Zovea vs Vilden (zovea will start with +5 bc he is unpopular)
  • Battle 4 - Private vs Sonseray

Semi final:

  • JeffreyAaron vs Winner of Battle 2
  • Winner of Battle 3 vs Winner of Battle 4

Final: ^ the 2 winners of those

who is the better player?
12
Soda
10
Gerry
deletedover 7 years

Zovea says


Jeff says

Someone's effort to try and trophy will never ever be a representation of their skill as a player.


This is and forever will be bullshet and you know it. If you come here night after night and use most of your hearts, you're running whether you admit it or not. For people like you that know you suck too much to run consistently, you make this excuse to compensate for your lack of decoration.

I don't like the current system of running and think it should be altered to fit the lifestyles of people that do more with their life than stay on this site all day. Making arguments about who is what on this site while trying to ignore the systems in place makes you as dumb as you think I am.


You have a sub-50% winrate in your time on this site. You will never be someone good.
over 7 years
I definitely make this excuse to compensate for my lack of decoration. I could never trophy even if I wanted to, I'm just not skilled enough.
over 7 years

Jeff says

Someone's effort to try and trophy will never ever be a representation of their skill as a player.


This is and forever will be bullshet and you know it. If you come here night after night and use most of your hearts, you're running whether you admit it or not. For people like you that know you suck too much to run consistently, you make this excuse to compensate for your lack of decoration.

I don't like the current system of running and think it should be altered to fit the lifestyles of people that do more with their life than stay on this site all day. Making arguments about who is what on this site while trying to ignore the systems in place makes you as dumb as you think I am.
over 7 years
Battle 3 you say zovea is unpopular but you're forgetting vilden isn't the most popular either. You don't need the +5
deletedover 7 years
Maymay is better than you. Silence yourself, moron.
over 7 years
Vilden isn't a better player than me. The opinions of others doesn't matter to me. I'm glad that in ABC's efforts to revitalize comp, he included me. I didn't even ask for the 5 point lead, he just operates in reality.
over 7 years
Someone's effort to try and trophy will never ever be a representation of their skill as a player. I cannot believe you're as fuc'king dumb as everyone says. It's shocking.
over 7 years
Just because he's not the better player does not mean he isn't good. When you get stomped and obliterated in your poll against Vilden we already know you're gonna be crying that it doesn't mean your bad blah blah blah.
over 7 years
You quiet down.

You admit he's not the better player, but try to hype up his moment of fame. Is Gerry ever going to reform from GT/Trolling to compete for the top spots in this game like ABC? No? Okay then.
over 7 years
Although I voted for Soda, I know Gerry is a very good player. It's simple as that. You're ignorant because you weren't around to play with him. Quiet down.
over 7 years
Why not? If he rose to his peak and fell within a year he's not the better player.
over 7 years

DatGuiser says


Jeff says

As a better player than DatGuiser, I have come to offer my opinion. Gerry loses a lot of games he should win and Soda wins a lot of games he should lose. That's the difference. Soda wins when he should, and more.


I know soda is better. he also has like 10 alts that he uses to dominate this site. Gerry just has GT and troll alts.


Don't talk down on Gerry.
deletedover 7 years
Comparing players doesn't seem feasible either because everyone has their strengths and weaknesses, not to mention that everyone plays differently under diverse circumstances.

Every player mentioned in the OP is good in their own regard.

Jeff is pretty strong at towntelling and has some spot-on reads normally.

I haven't played that often with Dyl to really judge him as a player, but the last time I did play with him he owned me as mafia.
over 7 years
Unconventional like not lynching between cop cc's D1? Because that's a strat that can win you a trophy.
deletedover 7 years
Gerry doesn't tryhard much anymore, but he was really good when he did, in my opinion.

I think that his strongest suit was being pretty unreadable as mafia and being good at unconventional strategies, it's what made him so dominant in Jan2.0 in particular.
over 7 years
Playing on 10 alts doesn't equate dominance. Soda is good because he plays constantly and rarely has to contend with players that are anywhere near as competent as he is.

That being said I can't remember Gerry playing well on any of his clones.
deletedover 7 years

Jeff says

As a better player than DatGuiser, I have come to offer my opinion. Gerry loses a lot of games he should win and Soda wins a lot of games he should lose. That's the difference. Soda wins when he should, and more.


I know soda is better. he also has like 10 alts that he uses to dominate this site. Gerry just has GT and troll alts.
over 7 years

Dyl says


quo7e says

bigbadboy vs final winner?


This is james posting on an alt btw


b
deletedover 7 years

quo7e says

bigbadboy vs final winner?


This is james posting on an alt btw
over 7 years
Private is good
over 7 years

Dyl says

Remove private, anyone who hammers me in 3 way after i go 3/3 on day 1 shouldn't be included in this

https://epicmafia.com/game/6044349/review


No one is perfect, I messed that game up. Happens to the best of us
over 7 years
bigbadboy vs final winner?
deletedover 7 years
yh remove private for being wrong in a game
deletedover 7 years
And nah i haven't gotten over that game
deletedover 7 years
That game is expired but long story short i push on all maf day 1, private votes me 10 seconds into the final day and says something along the lines of "you're confirmed mafia"