Back to Epicmafia

Ask a mentor why you got lynched

over 7 years

Post a game link if you want a very brief analysis on why you got lynched in a game.

The purpose of this thread is to help you improve your gameplay!

Non-mentors are also encouraged to participate in this thread, but only current mentors will be eligible for points for each player they respond to.

Most helpful mentor gets a sticker or something~

deletedabout 7 years
me and my friend sammie will be continuing this
deletedover 7 years
This thread should've been titled "Ask bad players why you got lynched".
deletedover 7 years
Happens all the time tbh.
deletedover 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5923899/review

I pointed out things that would make someone scummy. I had legit reactions because i forgot that maximumpayne was jan. I also brought in the logic to the situation, where one person was almost scumclaiming, and the other person was carbon-copy ninja meta. Yet after all this, I get caught in a final lynch with two "obvtowns". I don't get it.
deletedover 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5923899/review

so far what I could get from this is that:
1) I slowrolled, so that makes me mafia
2) I try harded, so that makes me mafia
over 7 years

JM123 says


JM123 says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5842329/review

i really need a opinion on this one, how i got lynched is something that blows my mind




over 7 years
Your daystarts were all awkward and forced. You pretty much tunneled NLNLNL all game and had major confirmation bias. Plus you tried to wifom as caroler for some reason.

I'd say it was giving off nervous energy and trying too hard moreso than bad luck.
over 7 years

Miguel says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5886167/review

I really tried on this one pls help


Yeah honestly this one just came out to be a mishammer. I would've hammered Sherlock there. You played this well. Nothing to really say besides you drew the shorter straw.
deletedover 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5886167/review

I really tried on this one pls help
deletedover 7 years

Miguel says

funny how you come to this thread for constructive criticism on your play and then be all stubborn about it after you get your answer


imagine arguing your point of view to learn more about your mistakes lol salty!1!1!
over 7 years

JM123 says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5842329/review

i really need a opinion on this one, how i got lynched is something that blows my mind

over 7 years
deletedover 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5851054/review

the Edihg dream team is unstoppable
deletedover 7 years
deletedover 7 years
funny how you come to this thread for constructive criticism on your play and then be all stubborn about it after you get your answer
deletedover 7 years

Private says


RRRAAAYYYAAA says

i know why but i want you to say it too
https://epicmafia.com/game/5850093/review


Judging by this 3-way you did an abundance of things wrong.

1. when belochka asked you heads or tails, you accused him of using OGI.

2. when he voted you, you were still appealing to him instead of the guy who was not voting.

3. Once the second guy voted, you still appealed to the guy who voted you first.


You were the weakest person here and showed it. Belochka could have been made out to be quite scummy if you played it right, but you did not. All your lines looked really weak and fabricated. None of your lines seemed really genuine at all. If i were you, next time you're in a 3 way, show some emotion. Show that you actually care and want to win.
You should try to be less defensive, and more offensive(not like calling someone a bad word). Be more aggressive and call people out for their actions.

My go to when being lynched in a 3 way is piling on a buttload of Appeal to Emotion. Being hard to lynch usually makes you not get lynched in a 3 way. Good luck! let me know if you have any more questions.


i caught a slip on janitor in that chaos and cop has lawyer guilty so why would i buss i was clear there !!!!! the other guy has a problem with logic and you would say i was the weak one !!!!!!! Private really !!!!!!!! janitor got shot because of me !
over 7 years

RRRAAAYYYAAA says

i know why but i want you to say it too
https://epicmafia.com/game/5850093/review


Judging by this 3-way you did an abundance of things wrong.

1. when belochka asked you heads or tails, you accused him of using OGI.

2. when he voted you, you were still appealing to him instead of the guy who was not voting.

3. Once the second guy voted, you still appealed to the guy who voted you first.


You were the weakest person here and showed it. Belochka could have been made out to be quite scummy if you played it right, but you did not. All your lines looked really weak and fabricated. None of your lines seemed really genuine at all. If i were you, next time you're in a 3 way, show some emotion. Show that you actually care and want to win.
You should try to be less defensive, and more offensive(not like calling someone a bad word). Be more aggressive and call people out for their actions.

My go to when being lynched in a 3 way is piling on a buttload of Appeal to Emotion. Being hard to lynch usually makes you not get lynched in a 3 way. Good luck! let me know if you have any more questions.
deletedover 7 years
Uhhhhhhhh, Is there a way to link all of my games?
deletedover 7 years
i know why but i want you to say it too
https://epicmafia.com/game/5850093/review
over 7 years

iminthetoilet says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5849452/review why was i lynched day1?


Yeah, Brenda is right. Just stop playing that cancerous setup and play one that actually takes skill and we can give you a valued response.
over 7 years

Bazzo says

I still don't get how I was scumread so quickly though, I laughed at cop death but the other two didn't give any reaction, isn't that equally as bad?

By egging people on I was trying to look at the teeny weeny amount of game related content that I could in the previous day because no one else was doing anything, I really don't know how I was supposed to have played that 3way at all.


You still could have played it better in my opinion. You seemed to be the odd one out for sure. You should've came into that 3 way and immediately should have been looking for the other town. thats how you win that 3 way when the other town is gunned.
over 7 years
i'm really good very player i most of time get very bad mafia 2/2 but they no listen and lynch me coz i too good and maf bad bois (forgive enlgish im rushia)
over 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5849783

I open my eyes
I try to see but I’m blinded by the white light
I can’t remember how
I can’t remember why
I’m lying here tonight
And I can’t stand the pain
And I can’t make it go away
No I can’t stand the pain
How could this happen to me
I made no mistakes
I’ve got no where to run
the night goes on
as I’m fading away
I’m sick of this life
I WANNA SCREAM
how could this happen to me
everybody’s screaming
I try to make a sound but no one hears me
i’m slipping off the edge
i’m hanging by a thread
I wanna start this over again
so I try to hold onto a time when nothing mattered
and I can’t explain what happened
and i can’t erase the things that I’ve done
no I can’t
over 7 years
That setup requires a random lynch on someone who isn't president, so that the president can remain hidden. It's not anything you did.
over 7 years