dzanek1143 says

Honestly first games were 60% town win when people were scumhunting, taking the advantage that they know the president so they'll just try to find the mafia.

Now the setup is 47/52 because this idiot town keeps rl'ing all the time following the spy first to vote. Then spy NK so can lead second bw and lynch the town. If GS is lynched then sniper is safe and will never shoot until bw'd, if 2 bombs are lynched - mafia autowin.

Comparing ranked*2 setup and unranked one, the latter looks more competitive.

"Yes um, hi, I'd like to report a hitler in the thread...."

AsbelLhant says

So we can tell each other to kill themselves again?

remember that debate on my mod team.

So we can tell each other to kill themselves again?

Remove this set up, as it makes want to assassinate a real president!!!! (not like I would have the nerve too in rl though) :(

vilden says

5- if any mod even thinks of banning it, he or she should kill them self. We dont need such self righteous mods who cheat every game and think they have the right to decide how we have fun.

Hahaha

I l0l'd

Cruiser says

It's a balanced setup but it goes against of the spirit of the game. The games are far more hide-the-president oriented than scumhunting.

Honestly first games were 60% town win when people were scumhunting, taking the advantage that they know the president so they'll just try to find the mafia.

Mafia can be quite obvious and slip based on showing themselves clueless.

Now there are random bw. When town decides to random bw whoever is not president and town is lynched it's most likely mafia win. If they lynch bomb then smart mafia can take more than mechanical 50% from this. If spy decides to NK and GS guns the president then another bomb ml is enough for mafia autowin. If GS gets lynched then the smart sniper will never shoot if not lynched and some town still waits until sniper shot.

It looks funnier late game, town decides to scumhunt just when there are less people on, the scumhunt appears on 4ways and there's more chance to get the president shot, instead of scumhunting D1 where the chance getting the president sniped is the lowest.

Why doesn't B2NS go this way that somebody claims blue, selfs so pr will be hidden? Similarly CnO or STBS.

i thought you were going to post a conspiracy theory about jfk's assassination

was disappointed pranay

This website has gone beyond the creator's imagination long ago. You guys are too narrow minded and too stupid if you think sniper can get lucky all the time. The risk is too high and if you take an informed guess then you will be rewarded.

It's a balanced setup but it goes against of the spirit of the game. The games are far more hide-the-president oriented than scumhunting. There's a possibility sniper gets lucky and hipfires president to end the game in an instant. Any setup that can instantly end isn't comp viable. As someone else said-it's just red hearts anyway but it probably shouldn't be a featured setup.

Hunt says

It doesn't always have to be a particular way to be mafia. Your opinion of mafia is clouded by your narrow perception.

I guess it depends on how you define mafia. I would define it the same way its creator defined it, which is an uninformed majority vs an informed minority.

Using that definition, this setup is not, by definition, a game of mafia.

It doesn't always have to be a particular way to be mafia. Your opinion of mafia is clouded by your narrow perception.

Hunt says

Some people can't expand their skills. They can only play old fashioned mafia. Any variation in the game being enjoyed by others is mind boggling for them. This setup requires very special skill. The point of having different setups is to have different kinds of strategic motive.

Pranay, it is literally not mafia, it is a variation of the game ghost in the games lobby.

It certainly shouldn't be featured and it probably shouldn't be allowed in main lobby at all.

Move it to games lobby.

Some people can't expand their skills. They can only play old fashioned mafia. Any variation in the game being enjoyed by others is mind boggling for them. This setup requires very special skill. The point of having different setups is to have different kinds of strategic motive.

should be banned, it is not mafia, it is ghost.

9- should be blacklisted

jfk is a fun setup, it's just red hearts anyway

This thread here is official communication that no mod will ban this setup. If they want to, they first have to clarify everything here.

People who hate this setup are the same people who think ISP is a good strategy

8- By disrespecting this setup you are disrespecting John F. Kennedy and the struggles the American people had to go through after his assassination. Don't desecrate the dead.

Now lets play one https://epicmafia.com/game/5712876