over 8 years

Sign-ups are now closed. Roles are being sent out, the game starts at 12:00 AM EST on Monday, June 13.

If you wish to be a substitution, please PM this account.


Here's some guidelines to the game courtesy of mist:

http://pastebin.com/kEUDw4T9


Sample Role PM:

Welcome to Forum Mafia 17, Matt.

Your role is Vanilla Townie, sided with the town.

Your only power in this game is your voice and your vote. Good luck.

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.


Scumhunt your heart this game out if you're town or towntell like none other if you're not, because the player that Jeff and I feel plays the best game will receive a 20 token prize!!!

deletedover 8 years
i feel way more comfortable staying on pap. i'm not sure about shrub. i honestly think he's just not the smartest town. i don't know when i'm getting back from work tonight so i may miss the final lynch, but i'm leaving my vote when it is. i think with all this arguing we're going to end up nling and that seems to be what pap wants.
over 8 years
Vote Shrub. I don't think he would vote the way he did as town (leaving a vote up and allowing maf to blitz when this is possible MYLO)

I'm also not sure in PonyLove and Pap.
over 8 years
I'm voting in Papuito, Shrub, PonyLove. Idk which lol
over 8 years
izzy's vote count looks correct so roll with that.

DEADLINE IS IN 9 HOURS AND 52 MINUTES FROM THIS POST
over 8 years
My main problem with Pap is that everyone wants him. And he's both an easy Lynch as town and an easy bus as mafia.
over 8 years
It also doesn't help that I can't read antikrist for the life of me
over 8 years
Yes, and hasn't unvoted, which imo is scummy because he knows this is possible MYLO. He also said he thinks, if there are three mafia, the third one is in Gerry and I. Both of us have expressed interest in lynching Papuito. How does it make sense for him to vote Pap and be afk when he has those reads? He would be more careful as town imo
deletedover 8 years
Minecraftfangirlftw (0)
Gerry (0)
Dorzel (0)
izzy (0)
Mori (0)
papuito (2) Shrub, izzy
PonyLove (0)
Shrub (1) Mori

Not voting (7) Gerry papuito PonyLove Dorzel Minecraftfangirlftw
deletedover 8 years

Mori says

Shrub voting Papuito so freely while he is AFK makes me uneasy.


shrub voted way back, on page 151
over 8 years
Oh well. I'll be watching this thread.

Vote: Shrub
over 8 years
For example: he knows who the mafia are, and will say so, but won't hard push on them or even get them lynched when it comes to it. This is particularly evident with ThirdAug.
over 8 years
It's true he had good reads, but didn't commit to them - which makes me think he has more information than me.
over 8 years
I'm actually wanting Shrub at the moment. I would like Dorzel and Gerry to tell me how they feel about that.
over 8 years
Shrub voting Papuito so freely while he is AFK makes me uneasy.
deletedover 8 years
Minecraftfangirlftw (0)
Gerry (0)
Dorzel (0)
izzy (0)
Mori (0)
papuito (2) Shrub, izzy
PonyLove (0)
Shrub (0)

Not voting (7) Gerry Mori papuito PonyLove Dorzel Minecraftfangirlftw

unless shrub unvoted at some point, here's the vote log
over 8 years
It's not even about him being ISP or not, it's about the fact when he does post, it lacks substance and he is not towny. I also don't like the fact he only appealed to Dorzel when practically everyone in the game wants him.
deletedover 8 years
My response to pony from here on out:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnkU9GMArCU
over 8 years
I think we should decide on a lynch now. For three days straight, Pap has asked for more time and not to Lynch him while he is at work. I think he might be pushing for a nl cause he had more than enough time to post and change our minds.
over 8 years

papuito says


Gerry says

papuito who do you think the mafia teams could be


So the reason i want pony more than shrub is for pony their reads have kinda been all over the place like they are fosing everyone which makes me feel like she is most likely scum also compared to the others she hasn't towntold as much but it seems to me that she can fit into any mafia team here like interactions don't clear her.

shrub is townier like going based off interactions shrub can be mafia with izzy/mine/mori but i townread all of them which is why i don't want him lynched. So like typing this i realized i kinda contradicted myself so what i am gonna do is look into interactions between shrub and pony and see because that doesn't sound as crazy as i said it did before. I wanna know what you guys think of it aswell after i share my thoughts.




Read Shrub's reaction when he panicked cause I was hard pushing on imsohappy to get her lynched. There is no way that's partner interaction and if you got to that part while rereading your reads make no sense.
over 8 years

izzy says

and you'll just find a way to turn literally anything i say into "proof that i'm maf." as i said, if you want to lynch me, i am perfectly fine with it. because if the rest of the town goes along with the lynch bc of your claims, then we deserve to lose.


Look, you just called me town "the rest of the town" and there's nothing wrong with them following me on maf, if I was on my computer I could find so much proof you're maf
over 8 years
Yeah, they'd be ok with Orc, I mean, there's a million maf, it's better to kill Orc early on, why wouldn't maf want to kill Orc n2?

You didn't prove me wrong, think again. Your statements don't make much sense to me...
deletedover 8 years
and you'll just find a way to turn literally anything i say into "proof that i'm maf." as i said, if you want to lynch me, i am perfectly fine with it. because if the rest of the town goes along with the lynch bc of your claims, then we deserve to lose.
deletedover 8 years

PonyLove says

Me trying to make you look bad? Please, I'm just exposing the truth, everyone else seems to think you're clear...


"exposing the truth" according to you lol you don't even have a solid argument anymore since i just proved you wrong so i'm not even going to bother giving you any more attention on this matter since you think it gives your claim validity
deletedover 8 years

PonyLove says


izzy says


PonyLove says

I mean, I was thinking we should nl, cause this puts us in 4 way, but if there is the maf jailer, and 3 maf, we lose..

You don't have to wait for everyone, I'm still unsure on pap, I feel like he's attacking me cause the lynch is supposedly me/him, but I want Izzy/dorzel dead today


there is no maf jailer. wanting to lynch the clear is literally the scummiest thing you have said this whole game.


How are you for sure there's no maf jailer?


is maf jailer anything like jailer in lobby games? if that's the case then there's no way they would want to kill the orc. (i don't remember if dorzel said he killed itg or thirdaug, but obviously i don't need to explain why he wouldn't kill thirdaug if he was maf)
over 8 years
Me trying to make you look bad? Please, I'm just exposing the truth, everyone else seems to think you're clear...