what about drunk drunking sole mafia?

depends on who did what on purpose

right but who would be at fault in that case

they would know that the person who got saved 3 times in a row wasn't the doc.

if they choose to kill outside of the person who got saved three times, then that no longer fits the scenario i described and regular logic will be applied in such a case

let's say they try to kill the doc. They don't know the doc. Doc saves this person instead of the clear. Then what?

the current ruling is that mafia will get a gamethrowing violation if they try to kill the same target every night and meteor night knowing that doc will be on them and forcing meteor.

the doctor would not get a violation in this case.

this is the only case that gets special treatment

I don't get it though. Mafia tried to do an action. They didn't nl