Hibiki says

Gerry says

Mostly no. But, I do feel like in some setups there are. Like in BV you can tell when someone is nilla or godfather sometimes

actually it's those kind of setups where i think the role is unreadable.

only stuff like lawyered mafia in 10p setups usually

This. Lawyer is also fairly possible to read, I do also believe that a lot of the role reading is pseduo scum hunting though, and is just used to make people sound better than they are.

there is no thought process to playing epicmafia, so I don't know what those people are talking about tbh

I would expect it to depend on the person occupying the role. Like, some people are more likely to think about their role (and strategy in general) during the day than others are... right?

reading hooker and lawyer is a thing

you could read hooker on that setup i trophied in

Gerry says

Mostly no. But, I do feel like in some setups there are. Like in BV you can tell when someone is nilla or godfather sometimes

actually it's those kind of setups where i think the role is unreadable.

only stuff like lawyered mafia in 10p setups usually

Mostly no. But, I do feel like in some setups there are. Like in BV you can tell when someone is nilla or godfather sometimes

No.

Thnx i sort of understand what you guys are getting at.

Still 99% of it is BS though im pretty sure

It all depends. If your the most important role on the mafia side you prob need to play a different than say the nilla or who ever is ccing the first role..

if that makes sense..

the idea is that lawyer might play differently because they will always get guiltied, so some people might bus more heavily so they won't get checked as a lawyer.

typically, theres a role thats most important in that setup, and you are probably going to play differently because of this. for example if you're nilla and it looks like your hooker might get lynched, you might start acting more scummy to protect them blah blah blah blah

there isn't a major difference but there is sometimes a slight difference, like x mafia is oftentimes more likely to do y than the others, it isn't somethings to use in every single game though

more important mafia roles like hooker in a&v can tend to be a little more nervous but i don't think that's a reliable read

there's a difference.

they just say that to sound smarts they are dumbs

escurai, we are smart

i personally don't believe that there are blanket tells or actions that can be attributed to specific mafia roles