Anyways the meme is funny, but it's pretty clear cut eye knows scumhere and he lied about that in his novel length post. So he is in fact probably a cheater or at least meta abuser. He's also been banned twice iirc. That doesn't help his case!
But yeah I remember playing with eye and he was insanely sure that scumhere was town when the whole town fosed him. His reason for tring scum was because mafia tried to lynch him lol.
If all of those accusations are false, ThEye, dont attack poser ad hominem, just debunk each accusation in each game as cherry-picking or misleading or misrepresented or something. Getting angry and all flustered is only drawing suspicion.