Epicmafia

Graveyard no cheating edition

deletedover 9 years

We all know when your dead your able to see night/day actions and mafia or guns and whispers

What if we removed this in ranked your not able to see night/day actions you cannot see whispers(unless the leak) so poeple cant alt anymore unless Alt a is on town and Alt b is on mafia. Then alt A will still able to out mafia but this will decrease cheating by a high percentage

Should those graveyard features removed?

Not at all

Only comp

Only ranked

Only Ranked and Comp

deletedover 9 years

I guess im locking it then

Sanctify

over 9 years

WolfODonnellz says

Back to orginal topic again •~•?

the answer to the op is an emphatic No.

deletedover 9 years

Back to orginal topic again •~•?

Sanctify

over 9 years

then again ppl are just gonna make alts and bypass the limit if it is in place anyways

Sanctify

over 9 years

like i said, the hard limit idea would be pretty bad obviously, it would be a community wide idea, and it could be bent in certain scenarios. Like the round is going on an extra day or something. Or you go to 17 games instead of 15...

Sanctify

over 9 years

AdrenalineMime says

doesn't having player limits suck for ppl in non-US timezones

or just general patterns of when you play mafia throughout the day

yeah, but so does getting banned because u played a lot of games with your friend.

deletedover 9 years

1 round more to win
>can't play it because your friend is already in and them somoene takes gold

AdrenalineMime

over 9 years

doesn't having player limits suck for ppl in non-US timezones

or just general patterns of when you play mafia throughout the day

Sanctify

over 9 years

lucids last few posts wer alright, i think a community limit should be established since people are constantly confusing playing with friends and not particularly fos'ing them as cheating. (gerryoats and Zwink's cases are perfect examples)

have like a 15 game limit per round if you're trophy running with any given person.

<< this format was really cool too

deletedover 9 years

Sanctify says

push says

making it so graveyard cant see everything in ranked is a good idea and would actually stop cheating which is the MAIN problem on this site. it is a big change, but so what. it's not that bad if you actually think about it

it wouldn't stop cheating dude.

Wouldnt stop but decreases the chances on cheating
Because you have less information when Alt a or b dies

push

over 9 years

Sanctify says

push says

making it so graveyard cant see everything in ranked is a good idea and would actually stop cheating which is the MAIN problem on this site. it is a big change, but so what. it's not that bad if you actually think about it

it wouldn't stop cheating dude.

it would in fact stop the worst kind of cheating where the person in the graveyard tells everything to someone still in the game

pereking

over 9 years

people that can only play during a certain time of day when fewer people are online won't be able to play comp if you put in a hard restriction

Sanctify

over 9 years

push says

making it so graveyard cant see everything in ranked is a good idea and would actually stop cheating which is the MAIN problem on this site. it is a big change, but so what. it's not that bad if you actually think about it

it wouldn't stop cheating dude.

Giga13

over 9 years

admin says

Alright, scratch that. I am building the proposed tool to see how many games a player has played with another for a certain round.

Thank you. The graveyard setup right now helps moderators find cheaters and proof against them sometimes.

admin says

It will be available this week on the rounds page, perhaps a warning can even be built into the game if you've played too many games with a group of people

This is ok, but as long as people aren't barred from playing a game simply because of the quantity of games they have with that user and their alts in a round, then it's alright. In other words, a warning is alright, but the user should still be allowed to play regardless of how many games they've played with a user.

push

over 9 years

making it so graveyard cant see everything in ranked is a good idea and would actually stop cheating which is the MAIN problem on this site. it is a big change, but so what. it's not that bad if you actually think about it

deletedover 9 years

And thus another feature will be created

Mission succesfull

admin

over 9 years

I can just build the gy feature as optional. Likely need this feature if necromancer ever gets built anyhow

admin

over 9 years

Or the most restrictive way is to hard code a limit to number of games you can play with someone, period

AdrenalineMime

over 9 years

i have no strong feelings one way or another

admin

over 9 years

It will be available this week on the rounds page, perhaps a warning can even be built into the game if you've played too many games with a group of people

admin

over 9 years

Alright, scratch that. I am building the proposed tool to see how many games a player has played with another for a certain round.

Jaleb

over 9 years

people for comp need to sit and wait for the table to finish more times than not. Let them enjoy it.

Sanctify

over 9 years

AdrenalineMime says

Giga13 says

AdrenalineMime says

Giga13 says

AdrenalineMime says

you should let people gy-spectate ranked games then

Uh, no

?

Are you suggesting we should let random people not in game spectate ranked games from a graveyard perspective?

If not, sorry

from decreased gy perspective (as in OP), yes

honestly nah cuz this could and will produce third party cheating, people will get their friends who aren't in games to spec it over and give them help with reads and it would suck.

just don't touch the gy

deletedover 9 years

>5 players choosed comp
>comp is serious play

Sanctify

over 9 years

this idea is sorta like the idea the democrats are pushing for the US, taking away guns to reduce mass shootings. only the gun idea is good, this one freakin blows