almost 10 years

1 Mafia, 2 Villagers

This seems like a good D1 instant Mylo scumhunt setup. I'm curious why more players don't use it as such. What are its flaws?

https://epicmafia.com/setup/1217680

What's your view
2
Boring
2
I don't care. I'm hungry
1
Mafia sided
0
Town sided
0
Boring
deletedalmost 10 years

TheeCake says


SlowBear says


TheeCake says

inferior to https://epicmafia.com/setup/325753


ah yes, four mafia, aka maf pointfarm central


with perfect town play, town wins 100% of the time


thanks maxwell
almost 10 years

SlowBear says


TheeCake says

inferior to https://epicmafia.com/setup/325753


ah yes, four mafia, aka maf pointfarm central


with perfect town play, town wins 100% of the time
almost 10 years
If you want an entry-level setup you should try sandbox closed setup.
almost 10 years
The name..."Just scumhunt".
deletedalmost 10 years

TheeCake says

inferior to https://epicmafia.com/setup/325753


ah yes, four mafia, aka maf pointfarm central
almost 10 years
almost 10 years
Goes back to Oracle but it's basically only effective N1. Or cop which if he doesn't hit a maf N1 is died D3 losing game any alts?

Maybe a random doc?
deletedalmost 10 years
i mean that's up to whether or not you have PRs in your setup in the first place. town MLing wrong isn't the end of the world anyway since a town flip can give much needed insight into interactions and such.
almost 10 years
Still won't work though if they ml wrong it turns back into classic with no prs
deletedalmost 10 years
easiest way to understand mylo/lylo vs. a ML is that any odd numbered amount of people being alive means it's either a ML day or lylo. i.e. 4 people 3 scum (7) is lylo vs. 5 people 2 scum (7) is a ML.
almost 10 years

SlowBear says


TheVigil says

Thought about the ancient Scumhunter's Speed 8p

5 town, 3 mafia. It provides a ml but no leads.


no, that's mylo. it's a d1 lylo if you're making it 8 people n1.


O crap true
deletedalmost 10 years

TheVigil says

Thought about the ancient Scumhunter's Speed 8p

5 town, 3 mafia. It provides a ml but no leads.


no, that's mylo. it's a d1 lylo if you're making it 8 people n1.
almost 10 years
Thought about the ancient Scumhunter's Speed 8p

5 town, 3 mafia. It provides a ml but no leads.
almost 10 years
I just need a good scum hunt setup for new players I'm helping. I tried basic variant but that was way over there heads...
almost 10 years

cute says

why are there two options for boring on the poll


Why not.
deletedalmost 10 years
if you're putting two mafia, giving town a ML is the only balanced and merciful thing you could do. d1 mylo setups are rarely functional. SDS is like the only one i can think of that isn't atrocious to play 100% of the time and even then, you need a stacked table to get a decent game of it
deletedalmost 10 years
why are there two options for boring on the poll
almost 10 years

SlowBear says


TheVigil says

What would help it. Basically make it classic?


i mean if you really wanted to test the waters, making it a 4 person 1 maf 3 villager would at least probably townbalance it a little, but it's still guesswork with only blues.

edit: you don't have to add investigative roles to balance it, i.e. super is a [redacted]


Thought about classic no pr 2 maf 3 blue. Or even 2 maf 2 blue Oracle to give town a clear
deletedalmost 10 years

TheVigil says

What would help it. Basically make it classic?


i mean if you really wanted to test the waters, making it a 4 person 1 maf 3 villager would at least probably townbalance it a little, but it's still guesswork with only blues.

edit: you don't have to add investigative roles to balance it, i.e. super is a [redacted]
almost 10 years
What would help it. Basically make it classic?
deletedalmost 10 years
town has nothing to work with and base any scumhunting off of. no n1 meta, no death reaction, it's basically a coinflip. that and the point payout would be ludicrously bad.