Epicmafia

Giga's Player Rating Thread

almost 10 years

The following is an opinion based thread on the skill levels of other players from me. This thread is no indicator of actual skill. There is no bias or anything other than skill in mafia games incorporated into these ratings. I will only move people up or down by a maximum of 1 level (e.g. Up to B+ from B) per game, because we all have good games and bad games. This thread was inspired by https://epicmafia.com/topic/67296 (credit where credit is due).

Post to be rated. There are six possible ratings, or tiers: A, B, C, D, E, and X. A+ is the highest, D- is the lowest. E means you probably aren't experienced enough to get a good rating but you show at least a bit of potential. X means I don't know or remember you well enough in games to give a good rating of you. If there are two or more people on the same rating level in Tiers A through D, I will rank them in order from who I believe is the best on that level to who I believe is the worst on that level.

Disclaimer: I will not rate myself, nor will I post justifications unless asked. Only the player themselves may ask for their own justification.

My Player Ratings List:

Tier A:

A+: Peta
A: Connor, Lashka, Sims, Shivv, BillStickers
A-: Anthony, bernin, Slowbro, Apostasy, Goodbar, FoodLion

Tier B:

B+: Quiet, Tatami, Gerry, hedger, kittykeri, Mischievous, Aura, Flea, SystemOverload, soda, NathanielArchibald, Polo
B: projectmatt, jagger, Edark, rutab, Calvin, Scholsey, Melt, Duke
B-: Stiffy, alise, Jackhammer, Ucklar, Rondar, Mitch, Eatos, TheOnlyJazznation1, ling, GMoney509, LaserVP, datjester1212, Pacifist

Tier C:

C+: papuito, Skillz, Shmeur, Sonrio, BearGuru, caroline, jackattack123, Schwartz99, CosmoStylin
C: mandevian, WolfBlitzer, Diabolik, xxerox, Perro, itg321, Jaleb, Orly, Amaranth, Smorlicious, IAmRobik, Shamzy
C-: FireDagger, gistofeverything, ptaqll, CaeruleumDea, Jiyeon

Tier D:

D+: PainFoinmr, AregVrt, Pinche
D: AbselLhant
D-:

Tier E: Tamashiii

Tier X: Pranay (gimmick alt), Ciel, TheShane, catboy, Bellerophon, NothinButTime1, tricksterer, Scumlord, Christopaz, Oulu, Surskit, n00bking, xela, Satan, Hydra, sweetnkind

(* section removed due to complaints)

ptaqll

almost 10 years

I should be up rank for thhe good guise imo

Giga13

almost 10 years

Updated

Alright I changed things a bit in the B tier and C+ level because I trust the opinions of other players as well when I haven't played as much or misinterpreted certain players

Giga13

almost 10 years

jackattack123 says

Genuinely curious why I'm a B I thought I'd be lower tbh

You've been alright in the games I played with you

Kerry

almost 10 years

mischevious also plays really well u need to add her to A- tier @ least dude

oh you don't remember playing with her. give it a go sometime soon, she's gr8

Kerry

almost 10 years

calvin deserves to be higher. he plays consistently and emulates his townplay really well. he's pretty much near impossible to read if he's on his game and thus you have to read other people to get his alignment or rely on reports

jack

almost 10 years

Genuinely curious why I'm a B I thought I'd be lower tbh

deletedalmost 10 years

ermagerd what about me.

PainFoinmr

almost 10 years

omg why i am C, i am so god

deletedalmost 10 years

Giga13 says

caroline you literally do nothing in every game i play with you unless you're mafia

HAVE YOU SEEN MY RECENT GAMES I DID A FLAWLESS JOB and this is funny coming from someone who isps bc he is watching ****

deletedalmost 10 years

Zedd says

HOW IS ALISE BETTER THAN ME

woah

deletedalmost 10 years

hi im going to be murdered by this tier, i know it

deletedalmost 10 years

HOW IS ALISE BETTER THAN ME

Giga13

almost 10 years

I don't feel like you're as consistently good as anyone in the B+ level

But I haven't played with you in a while, which is important to note

deletedalmost 10 years

why am i in B

Giga13

almost 10 years

I merge all accounts into one rating sorry guys

Giga13

almost 10 years

The B- tier is the hardest to rank because generally nobody feels like they should be there

newjerseynutjob

almost 10 years

I better be higher than Wolfblitzer. Also...I grudge ranked you for your ranking of wolfblitzer in my official rankings. Sorry giga. ;)

Giga13

almost 10 years

xxerox is generally underrated as well he got better recently

Giga13

almost 10 years

caroline you literally do nothing in every game i play with you unless you're mafia

deletedalmost 10 years

WHY IS XXEROX BETTER THAN ME? ? ? ?

giga is biased

Pacifist

almost 10 years

im better than pranay this is accurate

pranay7744

almost 10 years

shmeur better than me? in what? in busing his partner every game?

pranay7744

almost 10 years

i hope you know mandevian is me. and that there is nothing in which either of the players above me are better than me

Giga13

almost 10 years

Honestly I'm prolly wrong but if you read all the names top to bottom in a row it should be my opinion of best to worst that's how I rearrange it

Then I compare each person on each tier to each person above and below their tier to try and make it as accurate as possible (but at the end of the day it's an opinion thread)

deletedalmost 10 years

Giga13 says

Skillz says

I deserve a B+

I don't think you're as good as anybody in the B+ level no offense (again and always, imo)

I know someone in the B+ that I'm better than actually, but obviously I'm not going to say the name cause that'll bring hate.