Back to Epicmafia

Giga's Player Rating Thread

Giga13
almost 10 years

The following is an opinion based thread on the skill levels of other players from me. This thread is no indicator of actual skill. There is no bias or anything other than skill in mafia games incorporated into these ratings. I will only move people up or down by a maximum of 1 level (e.g. Up to B+ from B) per game, because we all have good games and bad games. This thread was inspired by https://epicmafia.com/topic/67296 (credit where credit is due).

Post to be rated. There are six possible ratings, or tiers: A, B, C, D, E, and X. A+ is the highest, D- is the lowest. E means you probably aren't experienced enough to get a good rating but you show at least a bit of potential. X means I don't know or remember you well enough in games to give a good rating of you. If there are two or more people on the same rating level in Tiers A through D, I will rank them in order from who I believe is the best on that level to who I believe is the worst on that level.

Disclaimer: I will not rate myself, nor will I post justifications unless asked. Only the player themselves may ask for their own justification.

My Player Ratings List:

Tier A:

A+: Peta
A: Connor, Lashka, Sims, Shivv, BillStickers
A-: Anthony, bernin, Slowbro, Apostasy, Goodbar, FoodLion

Tier B:

B+: Quiet, Tatami, Gerry, hedger, kittykeri, Mischievous, Aura, Flea, SystemOverload, soda, NathanielArchibald, Polo
B: projectmatt, jagger, Edark, rutab, Calvin, Scholsey, Melt, Duke
B-: Stiffy, alise, Jackhammer, Ucklar, Rondar, Mitch, Eatos, TheOnlyJazznation1, ling, GMoney509, LaserVP, datjester1212, Pacifist

Tier C:

C+: papuito, Skillz, Shmeur, Sonrio, BearGuru, caroline, jackattack123, Schwartz99, CosmoStylin
C: mandevian, WolfBlitzer, Diabolik, xxerox, Perro, itg321, Jaleb, Orly, Amaranth, Smorlicious, IAmRobik, Shamzy
C-: FireDagger, gistofeverything, ptaqll, CaeruleumDea, Jiyeon

Tier D:

D+: PainFoinmr, AregVrt, Pinche
D: AbselLhant
D-:

Tier E: Tamashiii

Tier X: Pranay (gimmick alt), Ciel, TheShane, catboy, Bellerophon, NothinButTime1, tricksterer, Scumlord, Christopaz, Oulu, Surskit, n00bking, xela, Satan, Hydra, sweetnkind

(* section removed due to complaints)

itg321
almost 10 years
idc if its suboptimal if i lynch scum it doesnt matter
Giga13
almost 10 years
Ya Nate I didn't remember l0l
deletedalmost 10 years
IMO, base it off win-percentage
itg321
almost 10 years
NL IS FOR PU55YS
Giga13
almost 10 years

AregVrt says

Lol C . Thats something


I was really close to putting you at X in fairness
deletedalmost 10 years

itg321 says

Jan 2.0 doesnt count Caro idk how to play that crapshoot of a setup and it should never be played for srs games


blame the player not the setup 0:)
Giga13
almost 10 years

itg321 says

explain the B- when i consistently win my scum games and consistently towntell well enough when im town


You sometimes make or go for really stupid play/mechanical choices and sometimes your reads lack real basis. I don't know what you go off of for your first few reads almost always. But you have results so B-
itg321
almost 10 years
Jan 2.0 doesnt count Caro idk how to play that crapshoot of a setup and it should never be played for srs games
deletedalmost 10 years
Lol C . Thats something
Diabolik
almost 10 years
samee
NathanielArchibald
almost 10 years

Giga13 says


NathanielArchibald says


Giga13 says

Goodness it's been years Splint I hardly remember games in which I played with you

Sorry but I'm gonna have to put you at X


Does that mean I'm professor X? =P

And it's been a year and a half, not years. XP

But no problem. I'll be around on this account.


Oh it's you lol ok give me a sec


WAIT. DID YOU NOT REMEMBER NATE = SPLINT? Lmao.
deletedalmost 10 years
you should read my two most recent games b4 you rank itg above me :itg:
itg321
almost 10 years
explain the B- when i consistently win my scum games and consistently towntell well enough when im town
Giga13
almost 10 years

NathanielArchibald says


Giga13 says

Goodness it's been years Splint I hardly remember games in which I played with you

Sorry but I'm gonna have to put you at X


Does that mean I'm professor X? =P

And it's been a year and a half, not years. XP

But no problem. I'll be around on this account.


Oh it's you lol ok give me a sec
NathanielArchibald
almost 10 years

Giga13 says

Goodness it's been years Splint I hardly remember games in which I played with you

Sorry but I'm gonna have to put you at X


Does that mean I'm professor X? =P

And it's been a year and a half, not years. XP

But no problem. I'll be around on this account.
Giga13
almost 10 years

Apostasy says

I demand justification for my -


Your scumgame is effective but consists mostly of screaming. You do anything to avoid being lynched as either alignment. Sometimes your reads are far off the mark. But in the end you play strong and you have the skill of an A- player in my opinion
itg321
almost 10 years
dont make me regret posting here
deletedalmost 10 years

Giga13 says


Mitch says

justify, also


If you tried harder you'd probably be A- at best, so I think B is a fair rating

Because you're probably better than you've shown recently


fair, also true
deletedalmost 10 years
It's because I don't have a gold, isn't it
Giga13
almost 10 years

Diabolik says

how am i not A+++++++


In games you tend to have no real reason for most of the things you do and sometimes I can't even understand what you're trying to do or say, apart from that you have results and you're not a bad player so I felt B- was fair
deletedalmost 10 years
I demand justification for my -
deletedalmost 10 years
ME ME
Giga13
almost 10 years
I fear I may have rated projectmatt incorrectly due to my lack of recent gameplay exposure with him, I had trouble deciding between B and B+
Diabolik
almost 10 years
how am i not A+++++++
deletedalmost 10 years
My life's goal is to get rid of that -