Epicmafia

Giga's Player Rating Thread

almost 10 years

The following is an opinion based thread on the skill levels of other players from me. This thread is no indicator of actual skill. There is no bias or anything other than skill in mafia games incorporated into these ratings. I will only move people up or down by a maximum of 1 level (e.g. Up to B+ from B) per game, because we all have good games and bad games. This thread was inspired by https://epicmafia.com/topic/67296 (credit where credit is due).

Post to be rated. There are six possible ratings, or tiers: A, B, C, D, E, and X. A+ is the highest, D- is the lowest. E means you probably aren't experienced enough to get a good rating but you show at least a bit of potential. X means I don't know or remember you well enough in games to give a good rating of you. If there are two or more people on the same rating level in Tiers A through D, I will rank them in order from who I believe is the best on that level to who I believe is the worst on that level.

Disclaimer: I will not rate myself, nor will I post justifications unless asked. Only the player themselves may ask for their own justification.

My Player Ratings List:

Tier A:

A+: Peta
A: Connor, Lashka, Sims, Shivv, BillStickers
A-: Anthony, bernin, Slowbro, Apostasy, Goodbar, FoodLion

Tier B:

B+: Quiet, Tatami, Gerry, hedger, kittykeri, Mischievous, Aura, Flea, SystemOverload, soda, NathanielArchibald, Polo
B: projectmatt, jagger, Edark, rutab, Calvin, Scholsey, Melt, Duke
B-: Stiffy, alise, Jackhammer, Ucklar, Rondar, Mitch, Eatos, TheOnlyJazznation1, ling, GMoney509, LaserVP, datjester1212, Pacifist

Tier C:

C+: papuito, Skillz, Shmeur, Sonrio, BearGuru, caroline, jackattack123, Schwartz99, CosmoStylin
C: mandevian, WolfBlitzer, Diabolik, xxerox, Perro, itg321, Jaleb, Orly, Amaranth, Smorlicious, IAmRobik, Shamzy
C-: FireDagger, gistofeverything, ptaqll, CaeruleumDea, Jiyeon

Tier D:

D+: PainFoinmr, AregVrt, Pinche
D: AbselLhant
D-:

Tier E: Tamashiii

Tier X: Pranay (gimmick alt), Ciel, TheShane, catboy, Bellerophon, NothinButTime1, tricksterer, Scumlord, Christopaz, Oulu, Surskit, n00bking, xela, Satan, Hydra, sweetnkind

(* section removed due to complaints)

deletedalmost 10 years

the one cheating ring that never made any sense to me was the rnb/kelly/mishanicole one, because honestly what could possess those three people to want to help one another

Giga13

almost 10 years

Calvin says

wait what matt12 cheated?

lmao

deletedalmost 10 years

wait what matt12 cheated?

deletedalmost 10 years

Giga13 says

Lashka says

NathanielArchibald says

BiIIStickers says

Apostasy says

Matt12 would have no reason to cheat, he is good enough to trophy consistently as evidenced by his consistent trophy wins (as long as Matt12 is in his games)

deletedalmost 10 years

roughnightbro owned i miss that dude, especially the time he was screaming at togepi on xbl during a call of duty game

Giga13

almost 10 years

Lashka says

NathanielArchibald says

BiIIStickers says

Apostasy says

RoughNightBro would have no reason to cheat, he is good enough to trophy consistently as evidenced by his consistent trophy wins (as long as Matt12 is in his games)

deletedalmost 10 years

Also, Edark cheated for nudes. Motive.

deletedalmost 10 years

Don't forget Endorphins, to prove he was the best player ever.

deletedalmost 10 years

Cheating is loony

deletedalmost 10 years

"x wouldn't have the motivation to cheat" is the dumbest argument against a cheating case ever, because the only people that ever had demonstratable motivation to cheat were cory and alessandra, and that motivation was "to crank the heck out of everyone"

deletedalmost 10 years

NathanielArchibald says

BiIIStickers says

Apostasy says

Fading would have no reason to cheat, he is good enough to trophy consistently as evidenced by his consistent trophy wins