deletedover 10 years

This idea wouldn't apply to competitive games, by the way.

When you're N1'd you don't contribute to the game unless someone votes you other than the killer(s) (for example they give you a gun) EVEN if you're a PR because nothing would be different if you weren't in that game.


Though, if you're N1'd and a cop gets a report on you, or a GS guns you, or an oracle votes you, or anyone with a night meeting picks you, then if you weren't in that game they'd have that vote on someone who was alive and therefore you did contribute to wether the town wins or loses.


For example:

If you were N1'd but someone guns you, then yes, you did contribute because if you weren't in that game an alive player would be gunned.

If you were N1'd and the cop checks you, then you contributed because if you weren't in that game the cop would have a report on an alive player.

If you were N1'd but NO ONE checks you, orcs you, guns you, or any role with a night meeting votes for you other than the killer(s), you didn't contribute because nothing would be different if you weren't in that game.

Add This
6 signed
Make it so that you don't get a win / loss if you're N1'd unless someone other than the killer(s) who has a night meeting voted for you.
Should this be added?
21
No
9
Yes
1
Good
0
Great idea
0
pls add
0
Add it!
over 10 years
Son, maybe this would be ideal for red heart games but surely not competitive.
deletedover 10 years
Kid is vague
deletedover 10 years
I feel like some of you just read the title and assumed it was no matter what if you're N1'd you get a refund.

Please actually read the post :3
over 10 years
I feel like it should be added with the limitations.

I've had a few days were I've been n1ed constantly and it's just tiring after a while to sit there and watch town fail.
over 10 years
I would explain why not but I don't feel like it
deletedover 10 years

Augustine says

YES YES YES


I agree.

No but seriously why not ;-;
over 10 years
NO NO NO
deletedover 10 years

JepoJ says

This is the best idea i've seen in all the "N1'd" threads!


Thank you! :3
over 10 years
This is the best idea i've seen in all the "N1'd" threads!
deletedover 10 years
I agree. There's absolutely no reason the person who dies the first night should have a penalty or bonus if they don't contribute.
deletedover 10 years
That's true, but that doesn't mean they contributed.
deletedover 10 years
well someone has to die
deletedover 10 years
Part of mafia is being N1'd and then losing after not participating AT ALL? Oh, I'll keep that in mind.
over 10 years
I agree with Mattthew, it would seriously ruin Mafia.
over 10 years
It's just really part of the game concept. Adding this wouldn't be logical, IMO.
deletedover 10 years
Then sign the petition and vote yes :3
deletedover 10 years
I dont get n1'd because Im female
deletedover 10 years
Well, no.
deletedover 10 years
Bumping the thread