if the mods wanna give it more plays fine, i guess but once it hits 200 then you really have no excuse to keep it unblacklisted if its still above 57/42 mafia
point payouts are determined by town wins and scum wins in the setup. if town gets 70+ points for a win, then scum is obviously winning more in the setup, therefore one can argue that the setup is scumsided
deletedalmost 11 years
It wasn't a rule. It was a single, exceptional case that Bronto made to try to cure Competitions of the 'Gun Culture'. It got a lot of criticism at the time, then people realised they could get around with A&R and A&V and thus nobody cares.
There is no rule anywhere about points payouts. There are rules about extreme scumsidedness, of which Trinity at 58% is right on the cusp of, and also extreme townsidedness (which is essentially anything at 54%+ because probability states that you will role town more often in all setups this is applicable too).
Payouts are irrelevant to both, hence why SK vs Mafia and Manhunt were both permitted to be comped much, much more recently than A&D's blacklisting.
deletedalmost 11 years
No I didn't
I am telling you bronto specifically told me he blacklisted it because he didnt like its payouts. You're wrong and right. I am right and wrong. He literally told me that's why its blacklisted. Did I say it was right? No. Stop being a douche
>Admin makes a rule >People accept it at the time >Now nobody cares
Whatever sue me for trying to follow a rule that's after your time as admin
deletedalmost 11 years
no. you can argue that trinity is too scumsided. i never said that was an issue. i never said trinity is a legit/balanced/OK setup. i'm pointing out that point payouts are irrelevant. read words
deletedalmost 11 years
I'm not even saying you're wrong, I am saying your a **** and you could have just told me without being annoying
deletedalmost 11 years
A&D was blacklisted because the admin didn't like it, and made up a reason to get rid of it. This failed, as people just play A&R or A&V instead. As both of these have lesser stats but get played just as much, nobody really cares about the bs reasoning used to blacklist A&D anymore.
