Back to Off Topic

Sonseray's Player Rankings

deletedalmost 10 years

Post in this thread and I will rate you as a player compared to the other players who post in the thread. I will try to remain objective.

  1. Crypto
  2. Lashka
  3. Shivv
  4. Keri
  5. Sims
  6. BillStickers
  7. Hibiki
  8. Projectmatt
  9. Slow
  10. BlackBattler
  11. Empire
  12. Anthony
  13. Bernin
  14. Apeescaper
  15. Giga
  16. Backinblack
  17. Renaldo
  18. Arcbell
  19. Jackhammer
  20. Subolg
  21. Sweeper
  22. Germatron
  23. Rutab
  24. Edark
  25. Theonlyjazznation
  26. Alise
  27. datjester1212
  28. Obama
  29. Jill
  30. Ediz12
  31. Gistofeverything
  32. Sammie
  33. Justrec
  34. JepoJ
  35. Uprizzle
  36. Onuzq
  37. BearGuru
  38. olorloser
  39. Caroline
  40. Happy0wns
  41. AregVrt
deletedalmost 10 years
Alise you try, though
deletedalmost 10 years
I like my place on the list, thank you sonseray
blank
almost 10 years
i'm bad at mafia
deletedalmost 10 years
Rutab is a good mafia player and not a bad mafia player. Rutab is a pleasure to play with, but a lot of good players have posted in this thread.
deletedalmost 10 years

Apostasy says


caroline says

how is this list objective? i shouldnt be below someone like datjester1212 like who tf even is that but i will ask one last time for you to take me off


I will not take you off. The OP specifically says "Post in this thread and I will rank you compared to other people in this thread" and you posted like 8 times. What were you thinking?


i posted to prove you wrong now take me the f*** off idc about being on your stupid list
deletedalmost 10 years

Sims says

most players are like that, considering you have an extra person to read in when you're a pr


nah, it's because i feel my best asset is being able to convince anyone i'm town no matter what, and that doesn't do me any good when i'm mechanically town
deletedalmost 10 years

caroline says

how is this list objective? i shouldnt be below someone like datjester1212 like who tf even is that but i will ask one last time for you to take me off


I will not take you off. The OP specifically says "Post in this thread and I will rank you compared to other people in this thread" and you posted like 8 times. What were you thinking?
deletedalmost 10 years
idk who datjester is but he's pretty good from what i've seen
deletedalmost 10 years
rolling bomb in SDS was honestly autowin for me every single time
Sims
almost 10 years
most players are like that, considering you have an extra person to read in when you're a pr
deletedalmost 10 years
how is this list objective? i shouldnt be below someone like datjester1212 like who tf even is that but i will ask one last time for you to take me off
deletedalmost 10 years
You'll all rue the day you didn't think I was a good mafia player when I 360 no scope a trophy away from you "pros" -_-
deletedalmost 10 years
i feel like i'm in a vast minority of players in that i play far and away my worst when i'm a pr
deletedalmost 10 years
i am hard for everybody
Sims
almost 10 years
i am a hard scumread for everybody. : )
deletedalmost 10 years

Sims says

i used to get a lot more compliments as a player before i won any trophies because i used to be way more analytic. my reads were also a lot worse. i think pmatt and arcbell fall into that same thing


yeah i think you played a lot better when i was on accounts that weren't mine, i think we just don't mesh as players well

pj's absolute best asset is managing to sound genuine in everything he does
deletedalmost 10 years
Shacky is a really hard scumread for me, but I'm not the strongest town player either
deletedalmost 10 years
arcbell was only good as darkbell, and that was because he tried his hardest to play the opposite of how he regularly played.
Sims
almost 10 years
i used to get a lot more compliments as a player before i won any trophies because i used to be way more analytic. my reads were also a lot worse. i think pmatt and arcbell fall into that same thing
deletedalmost 10 years
it's really beyond me how people think arcbell is that good. maybe i'm just pretty damn biased against the little dweeb.
deletedalmost 10 years

Lashka says

I am really struggling to see why everyone thinks BB was such a great player. I don't think even BB ever claimed to be a great player...


selective memory, maybe

i had an extremely limited sample size of games with him and he did really well in nearly all of them

sample size is why i cant put shacky top 8 either, because my go to strategy whenever shacky and i were opposite alignments was "needle shacky until he goes on tilt and gets himself lynched" and it worked like 85% of the time
deletedalmost 10 years
I think it's a pretty fair list objectively. I have a bunch of fourths, fifths, and sixths but I don't keep track of those because fourth place is the same as last place.
Sims
almost 10 years
that's a really bad list, friend.
deletedalmost 10 years
arcbell sucks
deletedalmost 10 years
I am really struggling to see why everyone thinks BB was such a great player. I don't think even BB ever claimed to be a great player...