Epicmafia

Lynch or be Killed

almost 11 years

Needs must lynch removed because mafia can force nk at night (even with must act since they can split the votes) and town will still be forced to lynch. Mafia are beginning to get smarter and are NKing for a large benefit, which is making the setup MORE scumsided

I'd like to hear people's thoughts on this

What the hell my poll options got switched around

"Both of the above answers" means Remove Must Lynch AND Add Must Act.

Right now, this setup is broken. I want to hear people's thoughts; I want to be Charles Xavier

Other (State by posting)

Remove Must Lynch

Add Must Act

Both of the above answers

Giga13

almost 11 years

Mitch says

there's no reason why this makes it more scumsided. perhaps the issue is that you're a bad player who lynches town a s town

Yes there is.

deletedalmost 11 years

there's no reason why this makes it more scumsided. perhaps the issue is that you're a bad player who lynches town a s town

deletedalmost 11 years

Onuzq says

Also, why do we give maf a chance with a dawn start?

because day start setups suck

Onuzq

almost 11 years

Also, why do we give maf a chance with a dawn start?

Onuzq

almost 11 years

The issue is that the pr's want to claim d1. If there wasn't the single pr setups I think people would probably feel better about it.

Giga

almost 11 years

Cantankerous says

Giga13 says

Cantankerous says

lobk is not scumsided because of that

I never said that it is the only reason. Again, it's one of the reasons why it is more scumsided than it should be.

actually that strategy has impacted lobk in 0 ways

Incorrect. It has affected it slightly.

cash

almost 11 years

if u guys play any setup where you do not automatically get mafia, and you play it in this lobby, it will always be scumsided.

deletedalmost 11 years

Giga13 says

Cantankerous says

lobk is not scumsided because of that

I never said that it is the only reason. Again, it's one of the reasons why it is more scumsided than it should be.

actually that strategy has impacted lobk in 0 ways

deletedalmost 11 years

ling broke it

Sims

almost 11 years

wasnt it 49/50 a couple of days ago

ling

almost 11 years

Lobk is scumsided since people rush the day 1 lynch, dont massclaim when mafia claim pr and also, its like 80% an scumhunting setup with just one ml and one clear max

Giga13

almost 11 years

Cantankerous says

lobk is not scumsided because of that

I never said that it is the only reason. Again, it's one of the reasons why it is more scumsided than it should be.

deletedalmost 11 years

lobk is not scumsided because of that

Giga13

almost 11 years

Riotkiller says

The whole point of Must Lynch is that town are forced to lynch.

Oui

Riotkiller says

Mafia NK'ing is neither here nor there.

I disagree; mafia nking causes mylo with no clears almost always

Riotkiller says

This is working... exactly as designed.

Maybe so (even this is debatable, since Gira's first post in this thread can imply that he didn't see that as a possibility when creating it--not saying if he did or didn't), but it's really scumsided and my point is that this mechanic makes it worse. You can say it rarely happens. Well, that's true, but eventually people playing it will figure it out, and the setup will become blacklisted anyway I think (soon), with or without it.

I like the setup though I'm not knocking it or anything

deletedalmost 11 years

The whole point of Must Lynch is that town are forced to lynch. Mafia NK'ing is neither here nor there. This is working... exactly as designed. What on earth are you talking about?

deletedalmost 11 years

catbae says

setup has core balance issues which are more important than a relatively uncommon occurence that tilts things slightly in mafia's favor

Endorphins

almost 11 years

blank

almost 11 years

honestly

the ppl who are playing are making it scumsided

seriously

deletedalmost 11 years

adding must act would wildly break the setup, by the way.

Clair

almost 11 years

this is y u play my variant

deletedalmost 11 years

town can force NL. it's all goode.

catbae

almost 11 years

have never seen this and don't think it's a major concern whatsoever, setup has core balance issues which are more important than a relatively uncommon occurence that tilts things slightly in mafia's favor