Hi everyone! While planning for my 18th birthday party (which is the day after tomorrow) I realised that I would love to host some IRL mafia. I am extremely experienced with hosting medium sized games of Mafia, but one of the activities for my party will be a 25 player role-madness themed game. The Theme for my party is "Fantasy VS Sci-Fi", so the Mafia game will have two Mafia Teams. So Far, here are my Planned Roles: Fantasy Mafia: 1:Ganondorf-Godfather 2:Voldemort-Can roleblock or votesteal 3:Sauron-If the Fantasy Mafia kills the ringbearer(Frodo or Gollum), Sauron gets a oneshot kill and a oneshot commute. Each time the ringbearer uses the ring, the chance of their Identity being revealed to Sauron Increases.
Sci-Fi Mafia: 4:Cylon-Traitor 5:Dalek-Sniper 6:Darth Vader-Godfather
Independent: 7:Littlefinger-Survivor, cannot be nightkilled, two-voter. 8:Gollum- Can target 3 people and find out if one of them is the ringbearer or target one person and kill them if they are the ringbearer, and take ring. Once he has the ring, he can commute on non-consecutive nights. Wins if he is in possesion of the ring at the end of the game-alive or dead. 9:Deadpool-Both Mafias think he is on thier team, He wins if all the mafia die and he is alive. He cannot be night-killed. He may peek during the night, but will die if anyone sees him.
Town: 10:Chell-Bus Driver 11:Fox McCloud-Tracker and reflects Dalek Beam 12:Zelda-Doctor 13:Samus-Cop 14:Harry Potter-Watcher, if targeted by Voldemort, both are roleblocked 15:Olimar-Starts with 3 random one-shot abilities, can use an ability or pluck a new ability. 16:Captain Falcon-One-Shot Day Vigilante. Triggered by walking to someone and yelling FALCON PUNCH 17:Laura Roslin-Confirmed townie, cannot be nightkilled, but will die on night 4 from cancer 18:Elsa-Roleblocker 19:Frodo- Non Consecutive night Commuter. Gollums kill will work through invisibility 20:Marty McFly- One-Shot Reviver. Finds out who is about to die each night and can choose to save one of those people. If nightkilled, will die the night after. 21:The Doctor-Non-Dalek nightkills will trigger a regeneration, changing his ability.5% chance of Vig, 30% chance of Doctor, 25% chance of cop, 20% chance of Roleblock, 10% chance of Watcher, 10% chance of Tracker. 22, 23, 24 and 25: Bran Stark, Arya Stark, Sansa Stark and Robb Stark-Masons
I will have two other people co-hosting the game. Does this seem balanced or not? If not, do you have any ideas on how to make it more balanced? Also, Because there are so many night-actions, what would be an effective way of co-ordinating the night phase? Also, If you have any ideas for other characters i could implement, that would be greatly appreciated. Thank-you so much for your help, and i will let you know how it goes.