Inspired by a graveyard disagreement I had with user Skillz in https://epicmafia.com/game/3386535 , I've decided to ask the forums who they think is right about the proper play in this setup.

In this particular game, we were on day 2 with a claimed tracker, dead BG, and 2 living players with no visit reports on them. One of the NVs claimed hunter.

Skillz believes that it's a good idea to lynch the claimed hunter with 7 players alive, because the hunter could be janned, and they'll be able to shoot.

My stance is that even if the hunter is this game WASN'T confirmed by the tracker report as non-janitor/stalker, that lynching the claimed hunter on a presumed 7p lylo is an extremely bad idea, as it would likely result in an automatic loss for town, as even if they kill mafia, the remaining mafia can simply force a no-lynch with the traitor on the next day. To me, it makes more sense to save the hunter for 3-way lylo, and lynch them then if they're still alive.

So who is right: me, or the guy who believes lynching the hunter on 7p is a good idea?