Or get rid of the guns and find an alternative...

The guns help prove someone is mafia. Should i get rid of granny then? and make guns completely prove mafia?

... mafia can't be shot, so guns are 100% antitown

that could work. but 2 dep 2 much. try 3 blue

I was thinking about changing GS to deputy. What u think of that?

it would make it a scumhunt setup with a mislynch and make GS just another claimable role that can confirm himself for d2

Kaioxys says

Why do you suggest dawnstart?

i would say daystart but that would be unfair to mafia not knowing each other

for this setup to work it requires GS not being able to gun n1, otherwise you have 2 chances to have a 50/50 shot at ruining the game blindly

Why do you suggest dawnstart?

^ i was gunna say that but i knew hed ask why

Broken. Tweak it and it will be less broken.

well lets see. gs is worhtless or anti-town, depending on the players. if gramps claim granny like you suspect town has a 2/3 lynch d1 so one of them should claim blue or gs that didnt gun. and in that case it would be nice to have a gun, but you dont because gs wasnt stupid enough.

it can become a mislynch setup if gramps hits granny, which makes it very swingy.

make it dawnstart if you want any chance of being able to make this a playable setup. it will probably need other tweaks too