Back to Epicmafia

Would you consider this GT?

SecondChance
over 10 years

So I'm trying to see if the following strategy would be considered GT on the part of the Templar:

Nilla should whisper to the outed Templar a deal offer. Identify yourself as the Nilla Mafia and tell them that they are going to be Yak'd that night but they can betray the town now to win with the mafia, since they will be mafia by D3. Tell them to out the name of their other Temp by asking for their claim in ALL CAPS in the chat. Then, tell them to lead a lynch on a blue. Yak and Stalk should not claim blue for this setup.

Is it gamethrowing?
11
No
4
Yes
Steven
over 10 years
It is not GT for the outted Templar to cooperate, similar to traitors playing to be masoned, according to official EM rules. It's just a low move
Ella
over 10 years
from the mouth of god straight to u
Ella
over 10 years

LaurieRose says


panthero says

it isnt even gt if you play for your future win condition. the aim is to win the game. if you are voting such that you will end up in a win in the end then it isnt gt. there is no such thing as current win condition. any mod who mentions this phrase current win condition is the stupidest ever.


Win condition is win condition lol

GuyFawkes85
over 10 years
Agree with JustAloneComplex and EmmerrLouise.

I was proposed that deal once, ignored it and outed the mafia. Also, the blue I selected was yak, so they could not even yak me :P (but that was luck).

I would consider that GT, because going against the CURRENT winning condition.
SecondChance
over 10 years
I actually agree with you both I'm just trying to get a broader opinion before it gets reported.

Also as a side side if you do not think it is GT please explain why.
EmmerrLouise
over 10 years
Agreed with JustAloneComplex - you can't throw against a current win condition in pursuit of a potential future win condition(as yakked mafia). At the time of taking claims, the Templar is still town and must play toward a town win. I'd consider it GT if he outed his Temp partner like that and/or intentionally lynched a town.
deletedover 10 years
Some people disagree but I think generally you have to play for your CURRENT win condition, so it would be GT.