Back to Epicmafia

Round 185 Discussion

about 11 years

Congratulations to the winners of Round 175

lolwot

Setups

kittykeri

Setups

carolineeee

Setups

Good luck to the participants of Round 185.

!

about 11 years
Honestly, I wouldn't mind a dethy comp round, mainly because it's still a difficult setup to play right, and one mistake from either side will result in a loss, more so than in setups with more players. Dethy is a game of logic, and lately, we've just had luck around here.

That's just my thought, though.
about 11 years

Aernas says


Loreli says

If armed & vested is replaced this'll be the first round in a very long time that has a whole 6 good setups in it.


You won't trophy either way so why does it matter?


Really regretting that 2/15 now.
about 11 years

Loreli says

If armed & vested is replaced this'll be the first round in a very long time that has a whole 6 good setups in it.


You won't trophy either way so why does it matter?
about 11 years
about 11 years
If armed & vested is replaced this'll be the first round in a very long time that has a whole 6 good setups in it.
about 11 years
who is fortuity?
about 11 years

Fortuity says

Congratz to all the winners of the previous round!

I already messaged lolwot about this but I didn't get any feedback. I don't think "lolkeeper" https://epicmafia.com/setup/985352 should be comp'd - The reason I feel this way is because I think most games of this setup would involve a lot spam and other users not participating due to the whole darkness when lightkeeper is killed. The second reason being it would be optimal play for town to no lynch until the meteor day as that way watcher gets more reports and can put those in their will, this could potentially force a no lynch unintentionally on the meteor day. As a whole the setup does look fun but as ranked it just seems like it would be a mess and I don't feel it fits the competitive nature.

As for "Dethy" https://epicmafia.com/setup/443825 - This setup is a 5 player setup where the first day town no lynch and the following night mafia kill a player which goes into lylo with 3 players. The three possible scenarios are 1) Mafia's fake cop report don't add up and it's town autowin. 2) Mafia directly or indirectly cc one of the cops leaving a 50/50 game 3) Mafia manage to fake a report leaving no clears at lylo.

The situation usually seems to be that conflicting cop reports results in a clear at lylo with a 50% shot at lynching the mafia. This usually results in a quick game and I think the whole competitive nature is for setups involving scumhunting instead of a setup based on cop mechanics. The point layout for Dethy also shows that it's town sided.

Do something quick pls! Time is running out, the next round is about to start.


If those are still up when the next round starts mods will force decomp them. Both aren't allowed in comp.

Hope that helps.
deletedabout 11 years
Congratz to all the winners of the previous round!

I already messaged lolwot about this but I didn't get any feedback. I don't think "lolkeeper" https://epicmafia.com/setup/985352 should be comp'd - The reason I feel this way is because I think most games of this setup would involve a lot spam and other users not participating due to the whole darkness when lightkeeper is killed. The second reason being it would be optimal play for town to no lynch until the meteor day as that way watcher gets more reports and can put those in their will, this could potentially force a no lynch unintentionally on the meteor day. As a whole the setup does look fun but as ranked it just seems like it would be a mess and I don't feel it fits the competitive nature.

As for "Dethy" https://epicmafia.com/setup/443825 - This setup is a 5 player setup where the first day town no lynch and the following night mafia kill a player which goes into lylo with 3 players. The three possible scenarios are 1) Mafia's fake cop report don't add up and it's town autowin. 2) Mafia directly or indirectly cc one of the cops leaving a 50/50 game 3) Mafia manage to fake a report leaving no clears at lylo.

The situation usually seems to be that conflicting cop reports results in a clear at lylo with a 50% shot at lynching the mafia. This usually results in a quick game and I think the whole competitive nature is for setups involving scumhunting instead of a setup based on cop mechanics. The point layout for Dethy also shows that it's town sided.

Do something quick pls! Time is running out, the next round is about to start.
about 11 years
Still waiting on bv, lana
about 11 years

Mitch says


thebrontosaurus says

Classic Mafia isn't allowed in Comp Lobby. A variant of classic mafia shouldn't be allowed either.


Agreed. It's a good thing that Evil Mans Must Die isn't a Classic Mafia clone.


yes it is
deletedabout 11 years

thebrontosaurus says

Classic Mafia isn't allowed in Comp Lobby. A variant of classic mafia shouldn't be allowed either.


Agreed. It's a good thing that Evil Mans Must Die isn't a Classic Mafia clone.
deletedabout 11 years
a
deletedabout 11 years

thebrontosaurus says


erotica says

good gifs bronto


Thanks man. the first one is me trying to go to bed with open reports, the second one is me trying to do them.


lmao
about 11 years

erotica says

good gifs bronto


Thanks man. the first one is me trying to go to bed with open reports, the second one is me trying to do them.
deletedabout 11 years
good gifs bronto
about 11 years
Classic Mafia isn't allowed in Comp Lobby. A variant of classic mafia shouldn't be allowed either.
deletedabout 11 years
GOOD SETUP IS COMPED? BETTER TAKE IT DOWN GUYS.
about 11 years

Owen says

I wonder how many people remember old school thebrontosaurus back in the Tweek days


Those were good times.

@Giga, not sure. I think it was allowed pretty recently. I'd love to take it down though because it's basically classic mafia.
deletedabout 11 years
https://epicmafia.com/setup/11784

this is a classic variant, is it allowed to be comped? (classic is no longer allowed to be comped)
about 11 years
Man. A&D, really?
deletedabout 11 years
RIP ShakeShake
about 11 years
I wonder how many people remember old school thebrontosaurus back in the Tweek days
about 11 years
oh look A&D is back
about 11 years
a mitch in time saves nine
about 11 years
why hello there mitch