Toadsworth can technically be Watcher... he IS Peach's Watcher.

Okay, here we go.
The last ones.
Watcher = Grand Eldstar. The most important Start Spirit and it watches all of the Mushroom Kingdom.
I like Dreamer as Rip Van Fish or the Subcon http://www.mariowiki.com/Subcon_(species) . You can give Hammer Bros the Blacksmith (no where else to put Toadsworth, so). Miller can be one of the inhabitants of Twilight Town or something. Maybe Vivian? The Agent could be that Paratroopa from Paper Mario who's a mailman.
Here's an interesting idea for Shrink: Nurse Toadstool. (: The only case of amnesia in Mario is either "Rookie" which is basically Bowser with Popple, and "Mr. L", which is, well, Luigi. Amnesiac could fit there as their alterego, maybe? Vent should be Count Bleck.

The rest I have no idea how they would fit in, so good luck and good job. (:

I only need 14 more icons... and if I do it in 8 days it took me one month to make this whole set.

Help me figure out the last roles!

peanut butter

New before and after pictures <3

Before: http://i.imgur.com/uHuBz.png

After: http://i.imgur.com/LK9nQ.png

Ghost house was too easy.... I wanted something better.

Luigi's Mansion, represent. I really like this one, too.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/luigismansion.png

>Graveyard image.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toadtown.png

This one was tough to decide on but I'm pleased with the result. 25x25 gives me much more freedom.

I built my own Toad Town with a few toad houses, a warp pipe, and Peach's Castle, and am very pleased with how it came out.

aww they're all so cute :3 upvoted

I think I've fixed them...
refresh your cache.

The caps are now more rounded, as are the spots.


http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toad.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toadsworth.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toadette.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/zesst.png

I dunno. I don't like the new caps for the toads. It looks kinda squished.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toadette.png

Toadette, Virgin.

Reuploaded Toad and Toadsworth with the new cap... not sure if I like it. I could revert them, keep males one type of cap, females the other.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toad.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/toadsworth.png

You might have to refresh your cache to see them.

I'm gonna use Worst's idea as Peach for Governor, Daisy as Leader, and Toadette as virgin.

That said, Daisy is done. I know she looks odd in the lower section, but it's because of her light skin color. Her arms are there.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/princessdaisy.png

Also did some minor graphical updates on Peach that I think make her look much better.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/princesspeach.png

If I start making enemies as town sided roles, Hammer Bro would absolutely be judge. He hammers.

Shy Guy for Amnesiac or Mason. Pick one.
Hammer Bro has to be in, so maybe Blacksmith? Sometimes they help... But not really. I can't think of anything else, so yeah.
How about Peach being Governor, Daisy becoming Leader, and Toadette becoming Virgin? I think it'd fit well.
As for Village, that could be Peach's castle or Toad Town. Graveyard is a Haunted House obviously.
Luma for Mimic (they can transform and shit). For Survivor... I have no clue. I'd say Jr. Troopa since he's basically neutral through out the game, but it's tough. Koopa the Quick is neutral as well, and he runs. Maybe change Traitor into a Red Koopa and Survivor is a Green Koopa? No clue.
Priest should be Eldstar.
I'll let you know if I have more suggestions.

Riddler what colours are you colourblind with? The insane and naive cop colours sorta look the same. One just loosk darker is all.

MostLikelyTown, we already have a cultist. It's snifit.

shy Guy 4 cultist.

>wonderful
wat

and how is it off? I'm colorblind, so I need a little help with those sometimes.

the pianta's look wonderful except the pink one is off.

Re-upped FLUDD because he was a pixel off.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/fluddhead.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/FLUDD.png

Might have to refresh your cache.

And now, the police force.

I REALLY hate these ones. The noses made them difficult to make. I don't even think they look like piantas but idk how to fix them.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/piantapolicea.png - Cop
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/piantapoliceb.png - Insane Cop
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/piantapolicec.png - Paranoid Cop
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/piantapoliced.png - Naive Cop

Two of them aren't really Pianta police, since in the game there are only two to begin with. So I just took two other pianta colors and figured: Hell, artistic freedom.

without is better

Yep, but I don't think he's THAT great...

FLUDD looks really good. You said he was going to be the Town Drunk?

Mushroom Chart?


Also, did two versions of FLUDD. I made it look as best as I could. Technically you shouldn't be able to see his arms from where I drew his head... but he looks empty otherwise.

No arms:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/fluddnoarms.png

Arms:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v317/riddlemethis6620/EpicmafiaIcons/FLUDD.png

Yoshi should be the jailer because he gulpz them and can choose to poo them out or digest bwahahahahaha.

Also where is mushroom chart?

As much as I like FLUDD for drunk... how the hell am I supposed to draw a front view of him? His nozzle blocks his face, and his eyes are on the side of his head.