you should do all nintendo characters in general, that way you have more accurate icons and a lot to choose from. idk if you used dry bones yet but he would be good for amnesiac i think

It's confirmed - if I finish this, it'll be an option on the site to use. As such, I need help finding ideas.

The only character I can find for Santa is the Santa reference in M&L - The Hollijolli Mayor.

Although I do suppose E. Gadd can also fill that role, but then who would gunsmith be?

should i move bob-omb to terrorist or leave him on yakuza
and should i make king bob-omb as either of those roles

so many new roles so much to fill in

Like Goomba, he's small. His feet and hands kind of have to be there. I'm gonna draw a bigger version, though.

- Tumble, the Party Host.
- Slightly larger, not a huge change.

Edges were too harsh for me on both of them.

Kylie Koopa - Journalist. This one was a lot of detail in such a small space. Hardasfuk

I like Merluvlee more than Merlee. Enchantress.

I had considered that since it would make this unbelievably easier, but then it'd be a more general Nintendo theme, not Mario. It's like how you never see Link or Kirby in Mario Party or Mario Golf. They're not Mario characters.

And if I make it a Nintendo theme, what do I do with all of the less-important characters I've already drawn? For each one of those there has to be an important character in some series.

Unless I limit myself to Smash Bros., but eh. Kirby would be mimic/amnesiac, Samus would be vigilante, Pikachu would probably be Paralyzer. Eh.

Why don't you expand out of Mushroom Kingdom and try something like Super Smash Bros so you can have better more variety?

Planned:
Arsonist - Podoboo or Pyro Guy
Jolene - Secretary
Merlee - Enchantress
Kylie Koopa - Journalist
Zip Toad - Celebrity
Party Host - Tumble


Also, this guy.


a lot of blanks to fill. haven't used every icon i have yet.
http://i.imgur.com/zJ96shB.png

All icons as of right now. Working on rearranging them by role. Added Whomp to the roster, he was a site icon before. Made it Interceptor, since if you try to run past it it'll "intercept" you by dropping on you.

http://riddlerrob.imgur.com/all/#1

just some quickies

two versions of boo - black outline and gray outline. the gray one is consistent with the older icons


Mr. L: Turncoat:
Rookie: Amnesiac?
Boo: Stalker.

I just remembered my issue with amnesiac - it copies roles. Linking characters to name alone bothers me.

Still, drawing rookie for now. And Mr. L, since it'll be easy.

Upon rewatching he does become somewhat forgetful

Well, if that's the case, go with Rookie then.

Whacka doesn't forget. He gets sadder with each hit and then runs away.

The only reason I'd be slightly against Rookie for Amnesiac is because he looks like Bowser (who is sided with the mafia in your set), whilst Ammnesiac is 3rd Party.

I'm pretty sure in the game Whacka would forget that you had hit him with the hammer, even immediately after you did it. Haven't played it in a while so I'm not too sure, would have to check.

Whacka can just take a beating tho, is he really an amnesiac? I don't mind it being similar, I do have dr Mario as doctor. Probably gonna do nurse peach for nurse.

the biggest issue with using someone like gaz is that he's a good guy, why would he be on the mafia's team?

Yeah, I only mentioned him because he was the only one I could think of that was anything like a ventriloquist.

Rookie as Amnesiac is a cool idea. I think Whacka is better because he won't be mistaken for Bowser.

Blooper to Blinder makes sense.
Pyro Guy from Paper Mario for Arsonist
Jolene from PMTTYD for Secretary

More to come as I think of 'em.

nah lol i love super star saga & partners in time. need 2 play bowsers inside story

@connor: felt like sarcasm homie

Characters I want to do but not sure where to fit them:

Captain Syrup
King Boo
Tatanga
Sonic (3rd Party)
Jr. Troopa

im complimenting your superstar saga reference because that game was sick, and tying it to amnesiac is pretty clever. nothing unprofessional about that

Connor, you're a mod now. Time to be professional.

gr8 ref 10/10