Balanced Fool Game

3
Seems pretty balanced. No doctor and prostitute means a cop can't claim D1 and a lack of claimable roles keeps it from becoming a claimfest.

Update 5/3/2011: I come back from a hiatus to discover this game is ranked. It is not balanced though and should not be ranked...
deletedalmost 14 years
Not so bad setup, I thought about this suggestion, this will be quite advanced setup that decides scumhunting in general.

1. Changing hooker into framer, it will give more chance of lynching Fool, the vig will be more important
2. Switch mafia with GF, that will make this setup very nice to play as fool. Mafia will try to keep fool to have safe GF and vig must try to kill fool to lynch safely.

Cop will be quite weak, but with some good thinking he can crack it up. 1 miller to protect hooker, if the guilty will be shown as mafia the village will know they got miller, which is actually buff to him.

Maybe allow whispering to have better position for village members and cop in general.
Conrad
over 13 years
The biggest difference between this and mine ( http://www.epicmafia.com/setup/288901 ) is the potential mislynch/misshot. On one hand, it forces the fool to weigh the benefits of ccing cop (which is good) since he can be shot n2. On the other, it gives the mafia another chance of accidentily shooting the fool, which takes a lot of the fun out of it.

Either way, the statistics show it as more balanced so far, so I'm jelly.