GT- Outs his role every game. And while you could say this is wifom, he does it honestly each game. This is playing against his win condition. Lead to him getting lynched as mafia. He did it as cop d1 previous game so it's bad as both alignments.
so the mods think a guy with 70% scum wr gt'd as scum and still won the game
deletedover 6 years
it's not playing to your win condition to claim hooker, and anyone that played with you previously (like charley) would know that you genuinely never lie about it and it's not wifom.
you know that at the very least you could just say "i dont want to disclaim my role" so you don't have to either lie and break your meta based off your profile (ogi vio, btw) or hardclaim mafia (which essentially boils down to gamethrowing)
deletedover 6 years
Nobody who's done any of those would win as much as I do.
And for what it's worth, Inever, I'm not mad at you. Like you said, we won the game. And I know you're not trolling, since you do it as both alignments. But you can't tell me you claiming hooker was playing towards your win condition my dude.
Us winning does not negate you playing against your win condition. You can't say "Oh I never lie, so when I'm mafia, my team can carry me and it's okay." You put us at a disadvantage by playing against mafia win condition, which is the definition of Game Throw.
deletedover 6 years
I admit that we were at a disadvantage compared to a normal mafia team, but we ended up winning, as you two thought on your feet and did exactly what was needed in order to secure us victory.
Belle even used the fact that I was outed hooker as an argument in LYLO by bringing up how she didn't CC on d1.
Every action has an opposite and equivalent counterreaction. There are multiple ways to play games, bro. Don't live your entire life in the box.
You said yourself town would never claim hooker. I do take it seriously, you're absolutely correct. IF you want to do that "I always claim my role honestly" thing, do it in sand box. But when you put your partners at a disadvantage by doing your "gimmick" and playing against your win condition, it's GT.
deletedover 6 years
70% out of 22 games is non-trivial. And bro, you take this game wayyyyyyyyyy too seriously. Reporting people for gimmicks is why nobody has fun on this game anymore and everyone is leaving.
I already explained how it's playing towards my win condition in the GY, won't reiterate and argue with you here.
You have a 70% win rate with sub 100 games. And the "honest strategy" as you put it, only helps if you are town. If you do it as mafia you play against your win condition, putting your teammates at a disadvantage. That is GT. You cannot say claiming hooker as hooker was you trying to win.
You were, in no way, forced to claim hooker. In no game is claiming mafia role town. You admitted as much yourself. Town would never claim hooker.
deletedover 6 years
Also, employing honest strategies, I currently have a 70% winrate as mafia and have won 4/4 of my games as mafia in competitive games this round. I know how to manipulate and give off fake partner tells while I'm outed. Not trying to lose in the slightest here.
deletedover 6 years
I was unfortunately forced to claim hooker, but I still tried to salvage the game to my best ability.
iCouldBeatYouUp
