Whether it is a Note or Violation does not matter, but what does matter is the precedent emily is setting by claiming my actions are Gamethrow.
To condone a player being able to blame me for their loss AFTER I was killed and removed from play is simply wrong.
The fact of the matter is that Smell could not find Mafia over the course of 2 whole Days where my influence was not present. He lynched wrong, and is unable to admit his misplay; therefore he must blame someone else.
Should we be reporting Smell for Gamethrow since he was unable to lynch Mafia? Should I be reported for not using Drunk role power on whoever was Mafia (25% chance?)
I did not play against my win condition - I utilized my Mimic & Drunk role power.
I did not fake claim - I claimed my role openly when I needed to.
I did not grudge vote - I voted who I believed was Mafia during the Day as well as the Night.
I did not force Meteor - I participated in voting to lynch.
I did not hipfire - This setup has no guns.
As for emily's last response on the original report, she did not cite any specific passage from the Rules page where it states that Power Role players MUST INFORM all players during the Day of who their Night action will be used on.
If this is the precedent you wish to set, then we may as well report every Power Role who does not state "I am saving Player A" or "I am investigating Player B." Additionally, you are implying that Power Roles HAVE to do what other players tell them to do, instead of making their own decisions on how the Game can be played.
Intentionally playing against your win condition or not playing to win. Includes fake claims made for any other purpose than strategy as well as voting someone based on a grudge. Forcing a draw (meteor) when you are not faced with an autolose situation falls under this category as well, since lynching/killing would give you a chance to win. Hipfiring can also fall under GT/Trolling depending on intent/scenario and is moderated on a case to case basis with discretion.
Jeff
