I vote no violation.

While it could have been cheating that won this game, I believe it was pure luck and an impulsive hipfire that won him the game. It does happen that town get that lucky. It does not appear that tcase42 cheated with Black which was the only possible way he could have had vision to know who the Janitor was. He didn't shoot the Janitor until after he claimed therefore he did not suspect him before that moment. If he really cheated, he would have hipfired the Janitor or another mafia role before the Janitor even outed his fake carol.

has no one here ever seen the caroled caroler mafia combo? seriously?

It doesn't confirm the carol because caroler can be janned, Definitely wierd

i shot him because he outted carol. I dont understand what you arent getting. I shot him because he outted carol. It confirms the carol or it kills a mafia. Its a solid strat

Caroler was hooked. There's no way you could have known he was fake without cheating.

I explained myself twice, no three times. I always hipfire the out carol, i either hit maf cc or the real person who was caroled. So we either ignore the carol or lynch on it.