You guys are . Just saying.

the whole probability thing is actually just subjective anyway, i would probably understand if it were something like actual odds but you just chose to lynch hibiki because he did something you didn't agree with. that's not playing using probability or a valid reason to ignore a scumread. so i'm just gonna sustain this.

If you want to talk about probabilities (which you seem to very, very much) if you say you think someone is mafia that implies you think the probability they are mafia is higher than the probability their cc (if applicable) is mafia. If you lynch the person you do not think is mafia it implies you are lynching the person with the lower probability of being mafia. AKA game throwing.

I don't remember when exactly but I know at some point way waaaayy back there was a ruling against policy lynching. You can't lynch someone for policy reasons, since they're not related to the game, it's just your own personal idea of how people should play.

why did you say you were pretty sure piney was mafia if you're claiming to have lynched hibiki for being most likely mafia?

http://puu.sh/dBEno.png This is grudge lynching. Also read the end of day 2.

Please read the entire game. I explain why I lynched Hibiki. It is not grudge lynching, though it may look that way at a cursory glance, but it is in fact based on PROBABILITIES.