ISP, Game 3433168, refund requested! This was given an ISP vio but no refund (by himapapaftw) in Report 112115 (by Orly), but this deserves a refund.

Compare this game, and eaglesbaby's play in this game, to game Game 3433168 and Weooo's play. This was given a refund for ISP in Report 112160. In both games, the ISP'ing player said literally nothing game related, even when prompted to talk multiple times, in both D1 and D2. The only important difference in these two games is that in my game, the town was better at scumhunting so the game didn't end after two days. Therefore, this game should be refunded! Also, eaglesbaby said basically nothing game-related D3 and mishammered a much townier person, who had also scumhunted well and fos'd the mafia over eaglesbaby.

To summarize: there is no important difference between the play of the ISP players in D1 and D2 of the two cited games, and the town in my game was much closer to winning, despite the ISP player's play, so my game should absolutely be refunded. The same mod, himapapaftw, even modded both reports.

I was not sure if this should be filed as a separate report or an appeal of Orly's report.