This is the second time you've mishandled a report and refused to read or acknowledge the actions of the player being reported before sustaining. The first time when shown that you hadn't read the game you deflected by claiming your job in handing appeals isn't to supplant the judgement of the person handing the report even if their judgement is wrong.
Most of the violations you give are community based and even then you manage to make that into a farce with the way you choose to rationalize situations.
You're not basing your decision on anything but you being complicit in making sure gameplay on this site remains sh!t. You down play him throwing in this game by comparing basic mechanics to being a robot as if he didn't have someone break down how he should base his shot for him before he doubled down on lying about having a report and shooting incorrectly. Him lying about his report directly led to his town read telling him to shoot me and his response to that was to lie and inadvertently admit to hipfiring me. Hipfiring is gamethrowing Arcbell.
If this was just a mistake he wouldn't have doubled down on lying in game while he was alive then in the graveyard chat afterwards. He made his intent clear, but far be it for you and your judgements on this site to not try to rationalize that away for him. You would think that you of all people would stop trying to rationalize for people by supplanting their actions with your judgments.
Yea the irony of this game is that I caroled hooker who should have been shot, lawyer confirmed a fake carol and confirmed themselves, and jan made themselves obvious to me by refusing to hammer the sheriff test
Can't do it because you asking me this means you didn't read the game, the reports, the OP of this thread, or the comments in this thread detailing the events of this game that you keep choosing not to address.
You're doing better in admitting you're wrong than Arcbell here who reductively admitted SeanP threw in this game but is, like yourself, choosing to supplant in-game actions with their own personal interpretations.
You asked me for evidence, your turn. You keep creationing rationals, but like SeanP when he claimed that he thought caroler was hiding and he ignored my lines, there's nothing in the game that can create that rational.