Super's Brutally Honest Ranking Thr49
Hello there, I am Super. Nice to meet you. I have decided to rank those who post in here on their forum mafia ability and seeing as I'm on my period (EW GROSS SUPER!!) I thought this was the best time for me to be truly honest with y'all.
S spf (as mafia)
Object (as town)
spf (as town)
B+ Matt12, nbtnbt5
This is a hard one to do because there is so much about your forum mafia ability which I LOVE. Firstly, I would say when you are mafia you are almost impossible to beat. 1) You are very hard to get a BW on because I think people are scared of lynching you/can't read you. 2) You know how to fake town-tell and are awesome at creating logically sound reads lists as mafia. You have fooled me as mafia twice now and it honestly pains me that I can't read you (ALTHOUGH I DID READ YOU CORRECTLY IN OUR LAST GAME SO I'M HAPPY ABOUT THAT... but that game ended and everyone was town so RIP).
Your town play is good, I think you are mostly correct in your reads but sometimes miss easy reads/things in games which can lead to your downfall. I also think you may be *too* paranoid sometimes - it's good to be paranoid about a player so your reads are flexible, but I also think you should trust yourself more (I think I am mostly saying this because of how paranoid you get of me, but I forgive you <3). I remember reading your diary in Uprising before you subbed in and you went 2/2 so honestly you are pretty great at getting early reads and I think you are mostly right in them. I also love when you use your crazy reaction tests to try and get a read on a player (i.e. Greek Mafia).
Anyways, I think your Scumplay is S tier and your town play is probably an A or A+. I think you are a very logical player - but could benefit from getting tonal reads from players when scumhunting (I saw you say something about AtE not being a tell - but honestly it is a tell if you can read into it properly, that's just the way I feel about it/how I scumhunt) !
You are a newbie at forum mafia (like me) and I love your motivation to try and improve your scumhunting abilities! It's hard to rate your playstyle because I think it's very different to mine. I'm trying to remember games I've played with you where I can properly rate you - because I feel like most games you either died n1 or got lynched d1.
I think as town you can get trapped as being a bit scummy so you're an easy push - but this could be because of your inexperience to the game and the fact you asked a lot of questions/random things in your first few games. I think your reads are fairly good - you can read me the easiest out of anyone which is nice but you also have a good grasp of finding genuine townreads on people. I think a mistake of yours can be not pushing hard enough/not being confident enough to kind of lead a lynch or really push someone - I also think you discredit a lot of people's reads when they can actually be a really good read (I've seen you question people calling out dumbtells etc in games when those players were actually town). But I also think this is how you scumhunted in those games (prodding people to explain their reads better).
I think you played an incredibly good game as mafia in Vengeful. You tricked me which was sad and I think all my reads were wrong that game lmao. You also were awesome to hydra with - and most people trd you :D
I'm going to say you're still improving and your playstyle is growing as you play more games. I'm excited to see you in your next game because I think you're improving so much with every game you play ^-^
You final ranking is: B+
I've really enjoyed playing with you the last few games and honestly after watching you in LOBL I was like "this is the best town player in our forum community ATM" - you literally went 2/2 and had solid reads the entire game which was honestly really impressive considering essa and shady were playing a really good game, yet you still called them out for it.
I love that you are confident when someone is mafia and you don't back down. You push that person regardless of what anyone else thinks and that is a really strong aspect of your playstyle. I also think you are a fairly easy read (for me) and Pokemafia was honestly really fun (until REDACTED) and we both had similar reads and you pushed on both mafia after I subbed out and I continued to watch you and cheer for you from the outside! Seriously though you've been going pretty much 2/2 the last two games you've played so I'm hella impressed by your scumhunting ability.
I haven't really seen you as mafia except for our forbidden action game and I barely read that/was trolling that so I can't really comment, haha. BUT we won? SO, you must be the best ;)
Town Ranking: S to A+
i am aware of my weaknesses so be honest!! i wanna see what you see
7.5/10 town game
unsure on scum game
9/10 town game
7.75/10 scum game
7 - 8 range/10 scum game
haven't seen scum game