pingu's thread9

pingu1mon 26d

I'm not a whizz when it comes to envisioning setups so this is a thread for anyone's and everyone's opinion. I'll post as I make setups or update ones I've already made.

415visits
0viewing
4
pingu1mon 26d
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1588257

Tried again at a setup I created way back when I was active.
pingu1mon 26d
deleted
Edark1mon 25d
Nice thread loser, would be a shame if someone......started memeing in it.
pingu1mon 25d
+2
your presence devalues any thread... time to delete this
bansheewhat1mon 25d
pingu
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1588257

Tried again at a setup I created way back when I was active.
I kinda think mechs are useless, especially with: Jan, Godfather, Suspect, and Cop sanities.

My honest criticism is that the setup doesn't make much sense, and the role synergies are weak to moderately strong at best. Cop + Doc is strong (even in Basic Variant), but with Cop being not so clear and having "two Cops" it's moderately strong at best.

But maybe it's just because I'm in the latest generation where having a clear who hammers is the meta.
pingu1mon 25d
I designed it like that on purpose. I wanted a predominantly scumhunt setup where the prs themselves are fairly useless at first but if you can work for it and piece things together, they can give quite valuable information.

Regarding the specific roles you mentioned:
Jan - The original had nilla instead of jan. I thought the original might be too townsided so I switched it for jan but I'm still not convinced which version is more balanced. I actually think the nilla version might be better?

Cop sanities/Godfather/Suspect - As I mentioned above, I had a particular vision in mind while making this that revolved around this combination of roles. Determining the sanity of the cop is a minigame within the setup and gives you an easier path toward victory. But, even then, each piece of information may still need to be questioned to some extent. Suspect instead of miller because I believe the latter would make it too mafsided.

I'm tired so I don't know if I explained my thought process clearly enough.
blacksnakemoan1mon 25d
+10
deleted
pingu1mon 25d
https://epicmafia.com/setup/1588349

I thought about it and I didn't like the bomb in the multi.
bansheewhat1mon 25d
+10
yeah bomb puts town in 4way