Clair's setup thread72

Clair1mon 7d
+1

Sometimes I get weirdly passionate about setups. I like to theorise tweaks and ideas for established setups and I like to put my name on them. I don't know why this pleases me, but it does, and it'll all go in here.

If you want to write or ask about your own setups please make another thread.

First and curent topic, infiltration variants!

1,545visits
0viewing
16
Clair22d 16h
Recidivism
Clair
ive seen and played BF2 and its not bad pretty good

diabolaerg is a bad role therefore so is ur setup
Also I'll remember that while I'm kissing Rose
LMAO

love this throwback
Giga1322d 16h
Oh never mind I missed a meme didn't I
Giga1322d 16h
Sorry
Clair22d 16h
+1
i'm breaking my own rule by analysing ur setup in my thread where i rule out analysing setups that are posted

but i really dont like the idea of someone dying because of a vote they made. imo votes should be unhindered at all times. its basically a vote-voodoo
Recidivism22d 16h
Clair
i'm breaking my own rule by analysing ur setup in my thread where i rule out analysing setups that are posted

but i really dont like the idea of someone dying because of a vote they made. imo votes should be unhindered at all times. its basically a vote-voodoo
The way I used it is pretty smart. Play it. Give it 3 tries with players who aren't pants-on-head stupid. Its 49/50 and legitimately pretty clever.
Clair22d 16h
i think it is pretty smart based on the theory in your strategies, but it really strikes me as not my kind of setup. im not playing mafia at the moment, i'd be open to play it for fun if i was.
Clair
but i really dont like the idea of someone dying because of a vote they made. imo votes should be unhindered at all times. its basically a vote-voodoo
diabolist is pretty smart; have you played rutab cowman 2? it's basically auto if you win cc day 1 because of dia wifom (did dia cc bp or did nilla cc bp)

voodoo is a role solely for unranked (and maybe troll ranked games with fool/ gambler theme).

the idea behind voodoo is people cant talk in in four-letter words or more. the idea behind diabolist is people has to vote correctly within the mafia (because dia cannot dia self, but can protect teammates from getting voted). it's an innovative role. comparing it to voodoo does not give it justice
Clair21d 18h
bansheewhat
Clair
but i really dont like the idea of someone dying because of a vote they made. imo votes should be unhindered at all times. its basically a vote-voodoo
diabolist is pretty smart; have you played rutab cowman 2? it's basically auto if you win cc day 1 because of dia wifom (did dia cc bp or did nilla cc bp)
that sounds genuinely awful actually.
bansheewhat
the idea behind voodoo is people cant talk in in four-letter words or more. the idea behind diabolist is people has to vote correctly within the mafia (because dia cannot dia self, but can protect teammates from getting voted). it's an innovative role. comparing it to voodoo does not give it justice
if you consider votes a means of communication like other roles on this site then yes it is the same. stifling a means of communication is Bad
Recidivism21d 18h
It's pretty fun dude, and more skill based than anything with a gun in it. Want to play one game? I haven't played in like 6 months but I do miss quality mafia with clair.

I may have to afk to take my 7 week old puppy out to use the bathroom when he wakes up, but other than that I have some time
Clair21d 17h
i'll take a rain check
i disagree with you that voting should be counted as a form of communication; that's why silencer/ fiddler is removed. if voting counts as a form of communication sufficient enough to affect reads and not just a mechanic that removes people from the game, then silencer and fiddler won't be removed.
of course voting patterns tells you something about a player's alignment but it needs to be paired with their reactions to getting voted or after voting. but a simpler way to think of it is that you get shot if you vote this particular person who can never be diabolist but can still be a mafia. that's not stifling any communication at all.

Players

No players added to the game yet
  • {{$index + 1}}{{r.user}}
    {{tag.text}}
  • {{result.username}}